Government · Bern
Swiss opponents launch initiative to enshrine voluntary e-ID in constitution
A committee of e-ID opponents launched a federal popular initiative in Bern on Tuesday, 17 November 2026, to anchor the voluntary use of the e-ID in the Federal Constitution. The committee has until 17 May 2028 to collect 100,000 valid signatures.
AI text based on reports by 20 Minuten, Le Temps, rts.ch and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On Tuesday, 17 November 2026, co-presidents Roland Bühlmann and Richard Koller launched the initiative with SVP National Councillor Rémy Wyssmann and EDU National Councillor Andreas Gafner. It has until 17 May 2028 to collect 100,000 signatures.
The initiative would anchor the voluntary use of the e-ID in the Federal Constitution. Voters approved the e-ID in September 2025 with 50.39% of the vote.
State digital wallets would manage only identity proofs and could not be used for payments, transactions or monitoring of behaviour. Protections could not be restricted by law or ordinance.
The Federal Council assured voters before the September 2025 vote that the e-ID would be voluntary. The voter booklet said a later law could make its use mandatory.
- September 2025Voters approve the federal e-ID with 50.39% of the vote
- 17 NovCommittee launches the initiative 'Digital Ja, aber frei' in Bern
- 17 MayDeadline to collect 100,000 valid signatures
A bid to write the voluntary e-ID into the constitution
A committee opposed to the electronic identity (e-ID) launched a new federal popular initiative in Bern on Tuesday, 17 November 2026. Its members include SVP National Councillor Rémy Wyssmann, who is a Federal Council candidate for the SVP, and EDU National Councillor Andreas Gafner. Co-presidents Roland Bühlmann and Richard Koller lead the committee, which was built around Nova, an association created a month ago to carry the text. Members of the Friends of the Constitution and the Aufrecht movement also sit on the committee, and all of them had fought the e-ID during the 2025 referendum campaign. The committee wants the voluntary use of the e-ID guaranteed at the highest legal level.
Why the initiators say the promise is at risk
Before the vote in September 2025, the Federal Council assured voters that the e-ID would remain voluntary. The voter information booklet, however, stated that a later law could make its use mandatory. The e-ID was approved with 50.39% of the vote, and around 21,000 votes tipped the result. Only eight cantons backed it, and the yes majorities in the cities were decisive. Wyssmann framed the contradiction bluntly.
“What is a promise by the Federal Council actually still worth?”
The committee argues that once the e-ID is linked to further services, its use would no longer be entirely voluntary. Opponents want digital offerings to stay open to everyone, so that no one depends solely on the e-ID.
What the text would lock into the constitution
The proposal would add an article 13a to the Federal Constitution. It demands that the e-ID stay voluntary and that state digital wallets be limited to managing identity proofs, excluding payments, transactions and monitoring of behaviour. The protections would apply directly and could not be restricted by a law or an ordinance. People without an e-ID could not be disadvantaged in daily life. Koller said he had nothing against the e-ID as long as it stays optional.
“I have nothing against the e-ID, as long as it remains voluntary.”
Economist Martin Janssen, who is part of the group, argued that promises by the state only carry weight once they are recorded in writing.
“State promises are only worth something if they are recorded in writing.”
Signatures, timing and the wider e-ID debate
The committee has until 17 May 2028 to collect the 100,000 valid signatures needed for a federal popular initiative. The initiative text was published in the Federal Gazette on Tuesday. Earlier in 2026 it was announced that the e-ID would not be introduced this year for security reasons, and the Federal Office of Justice cited new developments in artificial intelligence as adding challenges. The National Council approved a postulate in spring 2026 to review the e-ID law, including its voluntary character, within two years of entry into force. The Federal Council recommended rejecting a motion by Gafner that would have anchored voluntariness directly in the law, and Wyssmann said he would have supported that path. Bühlmann added that the infrastructure must be 100% secure, pointing to recent cyberattacks on refrigerators.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- 20 MinutenPopular initiative “Digital Yes, but free”: E-ID should remain permanently voluntaryVolksinitiative "Digital Ja, aber frei": E-ID soll dauerhaft freiwillig bleiben · original in German
- Le TempsFear of a mandatory digital identity relaunches the citizen fightLa peur d'une identité numérique obligatoire relance le combat citoyen · original in French
- rts.chE-ID: opponents launch an initiative for free choiceE-ID: les opposants lancent une initiative pour le libre choix · original in French
- Neue Zürcher ZeitungPopular initiative for digital freedom: Koller's fight against the surveillance stateVolksinitiative für digitale Freiheit: Kollers Kampf gegen den Überwachungsstaat · original in German
- Places
- Bern
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar