Diplomacy · Bern
Swiss committee backs double-majority referendum on EU treaty package
A National Council committee voted 14 to 11 for a mandatory referendum on Switzerland's EU treaty package, which would require both a majority of voters and a majority of the cantons. The full chamber debates the file in the winter session.
AI text based on reports by rts.ch, Neue Zürcher Zeitung, Le Temps and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
A National Council committee voted 14 to 11 to put the stabilisation part of the EU treaty package to a mandatory referendum, following the Council of States' September decision.
Passage would need a majority of voters and a majority of cantons, with at least twelve cantons in favour, a hurdle that Le Temps notes is far from assured.
The plenary takes up the package from 7 December in the second week of the winter session, with no return to the Council of States planned.
Press reports and NZZ point to a vote in 2028 at the earliest, after the federal elections in autumn 2027.
- 7 DecNational Council debate on the package begins
- Autumn 2027Federal elections
- 2028Popular vote expected, according to press reports
Committee backs a mandatory referendum
A National Council committee voted 14 to 11 to recommend that the stabilisation part of the EU treaty package go to a mandatory referendum. Under that model, the package would need a majority of voters and a majority of the cantons to pass, which is known as the double majority. The Council of States had already backed this route at the end of September, and the committee followed its lead. Supporters call the package 'Bilaterals III', and at least twelve cantons would have to back it. The full National Council still has to decide the question during the winter session.
- In favour
- 14 votes
- Against
- 11 votes
Data from the article text
A contested procedure
Supporters of the agreements argue that their influence on how institutions function justifies a form of referendum that the Constitution does not foresee. Opponents reject that reasoning. Delphine Klopfenstein Broggini, a Green National Councillor from Geneva, described the approach in blunt terms.
“It is a manoeuvre by the UDC to block these bilaterals, to close off from the rest of Europe and seal the borders.”
She argued that the approach works because the PLR and part of the Centre are ready to follow that path.
Four options weighed
The committee compared four variants and rejected three of them. It dropped the optional referendum proposed by the Federal Council, where a popular majority alone would suffice, and a transitional article in the Constitution that would have required both the people and the cantons. A compromise linked to the Compass initiative was also rejected by 14 votes to 11, under which a yes to that initiative would have triggered a mandatory referendum and a no would have led to the optional one. The committee chose the variant the Council of States had proposed, a mandatory referendum 'sui generis'. The transitional-article idea came from Free Democrat Andrea Caroni, a Council of States member. Implementing laws, currently subject to the optional referendum, would go to the vote together with the stabilisation part and take effect at the same time.
Timing and the vote
The National Council takes up the package from 7 December, in the second week of the winter session, and no return to the Council of States to settle differences is planned. According to press reports, the package is unlikely to face a popular vote before 2028, after the federal elections in autumn 2027, a timing that offers relief to the UDC. Reports expect the vote in 2028. The December session is already crowded with the election of a new Federal Council, elections to the Federal Supreme Court and the budget. The committee's majority complained about the time pressure and said it would have wanted more information before deciding.
Immigration questions still open
The committee took no position on whether the safeguard clause for problematic immigration should trigger a steering levy, a tax on immigration that the Council of States introduced. It said too many questions remain, particularly how the levy would affect the number of cross-border commuters and how high it would be. The committee asked the administration for a report on those points. A minority considered the existing information sufficient and the timetable appropriate. For EU citizens moving to Switzerland, the committee proposes that cantons check whether a person could endanger public security, order or health, and deny a residence permit if so. A criminal record extract would generally be required, although authorities could waive it where there are no signs of risk.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- rts.chAgreements with the EU: towards a double-majority referendumAccords avec l'UE : vers un référendum à la double majorité · original in French
- Neue Zürcher ZeitungThe thriller about the cantonal majority for EU treaties continuesDer Krimi um das Ständemehr bei EU-Verträgen geht weiter · original in German
- Le TempsMandatory referendum on the Swiss-EU package confirmed in the National Council, popular vote not before 2028Le référendum obligatoire sur le paquet Suisse-UE se confirme au National, le vote populaire pas avant 2028 · original in French
- SRF NewsNational Council committee wants cantonal majority for EU treaty packageNationalratskommission will Ständemehr für EU-Vertragspaket · original in German
- Delphine Klopfenstein Broggini
- Green National Councillor from Geneva who opposes the UDC's position on the EU package
- Andrea Caroni
- Free Democrat member of the Council of States who proposed the transitional constitutional article
- Places
- Bern
- Organizations
- European Union
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar