Kim Kardashian returns in All's Fair season two as the legal drama opens on Disney+

A second season after a savaged debut

All's Fair returns on Disney+ on 4 November 2026 with its second season, roughly a year after the first season debuted on the streamer in November 2025. Ryan Murphy's legal drama follows divorce lawyers at the firm Grant, Ronson & Greene, and Kim Kardashian, 46, is back as Allura Grant alongside Naomi Watts, Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson and Niecy Nash-Betts. Disney+ puts three episodes online at launch and then releases one episode each week. The official synopsis promises new alliances, strained friendships and a shocking revelation that threatens the existence of the firm, though it gives few specifics.

Critics and viewers pull apart

Critics took the first season apart, with The Times saying it "may be the worst TV drama ever" and The Hollywood Reporter calling Kardashian's performance wooden. Rotten Tomatoes gave the first season a 6% rating, and reviewers objected to cases that were settled through blackmail rather than legal skill. The Guardian's review of season two says the show has improved only slightly since its zero-star debut and remains absurd. Viewers saw it differently, treating the show as a camp classic whose awfulness is part of the fun. According to the BBC, it became Hulu's most-watched scripted series debut in three years, and Hulu ordered a second season before the season one finale, a double episode that aired in December 2025. Fans praised the Los Angeles interiors and the extravagant power suits, and stern described Sarah Paulson as the show's unofficial star.

Kardashian on the criticism and the bar

Kardashian told the Press Association that she thought her career was over after the reviews, but she found it funny that the criticism drew viewers in. Asked what a voicemail from Paulson said, Paulson explained that the message expressed what she believed about Kardashian's character.

“I was just saying the truth.”

Kardashian said the message gave her the confidence to double down on the role. She told the BBC that she keeps taking on difficult work:

“I always do things that are tough because I genuinely want to learn.”

Kardashian studied law for six years on an apprenticeship route that does not require a university degree. She took the California bar exam in July 2025 and failed it on her first attempt, a fact that her character's storyline in the new season echoes. Speaking to the BBC alongside Naomi Watts, she said she would sit the test again.

“I'll take it again and let you guys know once I've passed.”

Key dates in the run

The chart below sets the key dates of the show's run in order.

Season one arrived on Disney+ in November 2025, and its finale aired as a double episode in December 2025. Hulu had already ordered a second season by then. Season two starts on 4 November 2026 with three episodes, and weekly episodes follow.