Health & Education · Aberdeen, Glasgow, and Edinburgh
Surgeon calls for corporate homicide probe into NHS Grampian over 19 avoidable deaths
Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, wants police to investigate NHS Grampian after a 2022 expert review linked 19 deaths to avoidable surgical complications. John Swinney called the claims of the gravest concern but rejected a criminal investigation.
AI text based on reports by The Telegraph, The Guardian, LBC and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
A 2022 expert review found 19 avoidable deaths among 45 patients in liver and pancreatic surgery between 2015 and 2021, out of 31 deaths in total. Habib's estimate of affected patients differs between reports, from dozens to hundreds.
Habib and Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra want a corporate homicide investigation. John Swinney rejected a criminal investigation on Thursday, 19 November, while calling the claims of the gravest concern.
Swinney said he had not personally seen Habib's letters until 19 November and later asked the Permanent Secretary for a review of internal handling. A senior government source pointed to ministerial intervention in the board in recent years.
NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said a thorough investigation has already taken place and some work is ongoing. Health Secretary Angela Constance demanded full transparency, after the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report in the week of 9 November 2026.
- 2024Habib reports 20 cases from the previous decade to police; no charges brought
- Week of 9 November 2026Healthcare Improvement Scotland report criticises leadership at NHS Grampian
- 19 NovHabib press conference; allegations raised at First Minister's Questions
What the whistleblower alleges
Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant liver and pancreas surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI), said at a press conference in Glasgow on Thursday, 19 November, that he was putting his career on the line to expose what he called an "industrial-scale" cover-up. He has worked for NHS Grampian since 2014 and says he has raised concerns about the liver and pancreatic unit for about a decade with Healthcare Improvement Scotland, Police Scotland and the Scottish Government, without result. He said the unit has operated on thousands of patients since 2010 and that hundreds of them have had complications. He said expected mortality is at most 2 per cent for minor liver and pancreatic cases and 5 per cent for major cases, and he argued that senior officials failed to act quickly enough. He put the core allegation directly:
“NHS Grampian failed in the duty of care to patients.”
The 2022 expert review
An unpublished expert review from 2022 examined 45 patients in liver and pancreatic care at ARI between 2015 and 2021. Of those patients, 31 had died, and 19 were judged to have died from avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention. The review said liver surgery was occasionally "overly aggressive", with operations going ahead even where the disease was thought inoperable. It said pancreatic patients were often rushed into theatre without adequate planning, and that blood losses in both procedures were "unacceptably high". Habib's solicitor, Aamer Anwar, published the internal report on Thursday. The estimates of harm also vary: the Guardian reports Habib believes dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily, while LBC reports he claimed hundreds may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths.
- Patients reviewed
- 45 patients
- Patients who died
- 31 patients
- Deaths judged avoidable
- 19 patients
Data from the article text
Response at Holyrood
The claims were raised at First Minister's Questions in Holyrood later on Thursday. John Swinney said Habib's disclosures were "of the gravest concern" and that the NHS has legal duties to provide the best possible care and to investigate safety allegations quickly. He rejected a criminal investigation into the systemic failures Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra alleged at NHS Grampian, and denied the government had ignored the complaints. Marra told MSPs that Habib had written four times to Scottish ministers, three of them to Swinney, and said nothing had been done to stop the deaths. Swinney said he had not personally seen the letters until that day and later asked the government's Permanent Secretary to review how such correspondence is handled internally. Marra said families of the 19 people "deserve answers and deserve justice" and pressed for a criminal investigation:
“Hundreds of grieving families will be wondering today if it was their family member who died needlessly.”
Board response and wider report
A report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland in the week of 9 November 2026 found serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across NHS Grampian's acute sector. Health Secretary Angela Constance said patients were safe and that she would demand full transparency at every level. NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight responded in a statement:
“We are aware of the serious allegations raised today. A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing.”
The board said any new evidence would be considered through clinical, governance and legal processes. Habib reported 20 cases from the previous decade to police in 2024, but no charges have been brought.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The TelegraphSNP 'ignored warnings about slaughterhouse hospital'
- The GuardianCall for police to investigate Scottish hospital after 19 deaths due to surgery
- LBCWhistleblower demands corporate homicide charges against NHS health board
- The ScotsmanWhistleblowing surg calls for criminal probe of Aberdeen hospital 'slaughterhouse'
- Mohammed Habib
- Consultant liver and pancreas surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary who calls for a corporate homicide investigation
- John Swinney
- Scotland's first minister who rejected a criminal investigation and called the claims of the gravest concern
- Michael Marra
- Scottish Labour leader who pressed for a criminal investigation at First Minister's Questions
- Angela Constance
- Health Secretary who said patients were safe and demanded full transparency
- Aamer Anwar
- Solicitor for Habib who published the internal expert report on Thursday
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar