Diplomacy · Antalya and Panama City
Panama minister calls COP31 talks in Antalya hostage to a 'petroleum mafia'
Juan Carlos Navarro said negotiations at the Antalya climate summit are held hostage by fossil fuel producers, as 30 countries back a separate fossil fuel treaty outside the UN process.
AI text based on reports by LaVanguardia, El Confidencial, RTP and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Juan Carlos Navarro told a press conference in Antalya, Turkey, on Wednesday, 18 November, that COP31 negotiations are held hostage by a 'petroleum mafia'.
Navarro announced that 30 countries have signed up to forge a new fossil fuel treaty separate from the UN process, with Vanuatu, Tuvalu, Fiji and Panama among its backers.
The first draft of the cover decision, issued on Monday, 16 November, contained 144 items, and a new draft is expected on Thursday, 19 November.
The Adaptation Gap Report puts the annual need at $305 billion by 2035, against about $30 billion in contributions in 2024.
- Evening, 18 NovemberAustralian presidency and Turkish hosts convene a ministers' divan meeting on a revised draft
- 19 NovNew draft of the cover decision expected Thursday morning
- 20 NovOfficial close of the summit scheduled for Friday
Navarro's 'petroleum mafia' charge
Panama's environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, told a press conference at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, that the negotiations are held hostage by a 'petroleum mafia'. Speaking on Wednesday, 18 November, he accused oil-producing countries of contributing nothing to adaptation, to people's wellbeing or to protecting biodiversity. He appeared alongside representatives of Vanuatu, Tuvalu and Fiji, Pacific island states threatened by rising sea levels, and was applauded by the room. He said the world is trapped by an oil lobby that keeps demanding endless growth, and that people fall for it.
“We are in love with our kidnappers. We love the petroleum guys.”
A separate treaty and a warning on 1.5C
Navarro used the event to announce that 30 countries had signed up to forge a new fossil fuel treaty separate from the UN process, according to the Guardian. Backers including Vanuatu, Tuvalu, Fiji and Panama say it would fill a gap, since the Paris Agreement requires emission-reduction plans but does not coordinate limits on fossil fuel production and supply. Bloomberg reports the proposed binding treaty would curb the expansion of coal, oil and gas and coordinate a phased, equitable phase-out of production, backed by finance for developing economies. Navarro said the world had already passed the 1.5C limit, a breach he called probably irreversible, while fossil fuel consumption and output keep rising. He cited the 2023 El Niño, which he said cost more than $1 billion and endangered freshwater supplies for half the population of Panama's metropolitan area. He also accused producers of exploiting the people they claim to help, saying:
“They torture us for our own good, they destroy our planet for our own good.”
Talks stalled over money and fossil fuel wording
With two official days of negotiation left on Wednesday, the Guardian reports that unresolved issues include whether the text should recognise the need to 'transition away from fossil fuels' and how to address temperature overshoot beyond 1.5C. The first draft of the cover decision, issued on Monday, 16 November, contained 144 items. The Australian presidency and the Turkish hosts convened a ministers' 'divan' meeting on Wednesday evening, 18 November, to work on a revised version, and negotiators told the Guardian that countries were working on compromises, although a breakthrough was not expected. Electrification is another flashpoint: according to La Vanguardia the EU backs electrifying 35% of primary energy consumption by 2035, while according to eldiario.es the Arab Group wants that mention removed from the final decision. OPEC Secretary General Haitham al Ghais wrote that the world will need more of almost all energy sources and warned that electrification means more chargers and cables. La Vanguardia also reports that the EU is avoiding new economic commitments and refuses to name figures, with the United States having left the Paris Agreement.
Adaptation money and the closing deadline
El Confidencial cites the Adaptation Gap Report, which puts the annual need at $305 billion by 2035, while contributions to the adaptation fund reached about $30 billion in 2024. UNEP calculations cited in the same piece suggest that even tripling that amount over the three remaining years would not cover 30% of needs by 2030. The cost estimates assumed warming of 1.5C, a level that has already been exceeded.
- Annual need by 2035
- 305 billion USD
- Contributions in 2024
- 30 billion USD
Data from the article text
La Vanguardia reports that EU negotiators have declined to commit to a specific contribution to the adaptation fund, even though parties agreed at COP30 in Brazil to triple adaptation finance by 2035. A new draft of the cover decision is expected on the morning of Thursday, 19 November. The official close is scheduled for Friday, 20 November, and El Confidencial expects talks may run into the weekend.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- LaVanguardiaBlocks of countries face off in a tough struggle over financing at COP31Bloques de países enfrentaos mantienen un duro pulso por la financiación en la COP31 · original in Spanish
- El ConfidencialClimate shell game players assault the Turkey summit. Where is the fossil fuel ball?Los trileros climáticos asaltan la cumbre de Turquía. ¿Dónde está la bolita de las fósiles? · original in Spanish
- RTP - Rádio Televisão PortuguesaCOP31 marks time. Voice of Panama warns of world “held hostage by oil mafia”COP31 marca passo. Voz do Panamá alerta para mundo "refém da máfia do petróleo" · original in Portuguese
- eldiario.esCOP31 gets tangled without an impact goal: “We are kidnapped by the petroleum mafia”La COP31 se enreda sin un objetivo de impacto: "Estamos secuestrados por la mafia del petróleo" · original in Spanish
- Juan Carlos Navarro
- Panama's environment minister who accused oil producers of holding COP31 negotiations hostage
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar