Health & Education · Cork and Dublin

Cork University Hospital staff fearful of recordings, HSE chief says

HSE chief executive Anne O'Connor says staff at Cork University Hospital are not working together effectively, as a leaked meeting recording sits at the centre of a dispute involving the Taoiseach's office.

AI text based on reports by Irish Examiner, The Irish Times and RTE.ie. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Cork, Dublin · Ireland

A staffing warning and a leaked letter

Cork University Hospital chief executive Jennifer Kearney wrote to senior HSE officials in August warning of a shortfall of about 1,000 staff, which she linked to recruitment restrictions and delays in approving posts. She urgently asked for 172 posts to be prioritised before the busy winter season. The letter was leaked to the media, and hospital management has since been at odds with the HSE and Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill over staff shortages and patient safety. Carroll MacNeill has repeatedly dismissed these concerns, saying CUH has hired twice as many staff as budgeted for and suggesting the hospital is not managing its affairs properly.

The recorded meeting

Shortly after Kearney's letter became public, HSE South West chief Andy Phillips warned at a meeting of possible "performance management" action to bring the hospital up to standard. A recording of that meeting was released to the media. On the tape, Phillips claimed the offices of Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Carroll MacNeill had instructed him to speak to Kearney. Martin denied this, and Phillips has since apologised, saying no such instruction had been made. The Irish Times reported that official minutes quoted Phillips saying he had been instructed by those offices, and a tape it later obtained showed the minutes accurately recorded what he had said.

The HSE chief's account

Anne O'Connor, the HSE chief executive, spoke on RTÉ's This Week programme on 15 November 2026. She suggested the August meeting involving Phillips and senior CUH figures was recorded illegally, and said staff and outside visitors were fearful of going into meetings because they feared being recorded. She said she had confidence in Phillips and that his comments were made in a fit of frustration during a difficult discussion, adding that she had not been there herself.

“we have reached a point where people are just not working together effectively”

Anne O'Connor, HSE chief executive

O'Connor also dismissed calls from senior clinicians for an independent assessment of staffing needs at CUH, saying the hospital's staff complements, census and figures could be examined instead. She said staffing at the hospital had grown in 2026 and that the challenge now was having the right staff in the right place at the right time.

The Taoiseach's response

Martin told the Irish Examiner that he disapproved of recording meetings and was surprised to see it happening, arguing that it could change how people engage in conversations.

“I don't approve of tape recording at meetings, I'm surprised to see that happening.”

Micheál Martin, taoiseach

Martin said agencies such as Hiqa monitor patient safety and that one letter, or a number of letters, should not be what determines the outcome. He added that channels must be created so that consultants and others can articulate concerns more effectively, but that the hospital has to work within the HSE environment and that this would not change.

Pressure on the hospital

Nine clinical directors at CUH wrote to Martin in November about ongoing staffing issues, and senior clinicians have called on him for an independent assessment of staff needs. RTÉ reported that seventy patients waited on trolleys at CUH on a single day in the week before 15 November. O'Connor's rejection of an independent review leaves the dispute over staffing numbers without an agreed method for settling it.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Cork, Dublin

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar