Roberts preserves birthright citizenship and leaves Trump with a split court ledger
Continues from last evening.
The US Supreme Court rejected Donald Trump’s attempt to limit birthright citizenship, ruling that his executive order could not override the 14th Amendment’s guarantee for almost all people born on American soil. Chief Justice John Roberts grounded the opinion in constitutional text and the 1898 Wong Kim Ark precedent, while lower courts had already stopped the order from taking effect after legal challenges began on Donald Trump’s first day back in office.
“Citizenship, then and now, was the right to have rights -- to freely participate in our political community. The Framers of the Fourteenth Amendment extended that promise to 'every free-born person in this land.' We keep that promise today.”
Donald Trump vowed to seek legislation, though any bill would face the same constitutional wall and an awkward Senate count. The decision gave him a sharp defeat on immigration, but not a uniformly bad final day at the court: the justices also upheld state bans on transgender girls and women competing on female school and university teams, a 6-3 ruling that supports similar laws in Republican-led states.
The combined message was not judicial moderation so much as judicial selectivity. The court blocked executive overreach where the text was blunt, then accepted state power where conservative legislatures framed sex and sport as fairness questions. A court that stopped Donald Trump at the nursery door still widened the battlefield for culture-war lawmaking in the school gym.
Reporting from: Reuters, tagesschau.de, Financial Times News, Frankfurter Allgemeine, France 24, Der Tagesspiegel