Safety · Paris
Paris court sentences three police officers over racist beating of Michel Zecler
Aurélien Lapersonne, Philippe Tondeux and Pierre Plantier each received five years, with three to four years suspended, after the court accepted the racist aggravating circumstance in their 2020 beating of music producer Michel Zecler.
AI text based on reports by Courrier international, De Morgen, rts.ch and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Lapersonne, Tondeux and Plantier each received five years, with three to four years suspended, meaning one to two years firm, in a Paris ruling on Friday, 20 November.
The Paris criminal court accepted the racist aggravating circumstance, after prosecutors had asked for firm sentences of four, five and six years.
The officers' report claimed Zecler violently resisted, but studio surveillance footage showed about thirty blows with almost no resistance, according to the BBC.
- 21 NovOfficers beat Michel Zecler at his studio entrance, then file a report claiming he resisted
- 20 NovParis criminal court convicts the three officers and recognises the racist aggravating circumstance
The verdict
The Paris criminal court found Aurélien Lapersonne, Philippe Tondeux and Pierre Plantier guilty of all charges on Friday, 20 November, after a trial that lasted two weeks. The charges were voluntary violence committed by several people together and forgery of a public record by people holding public authority, offences that carried up to 15 years in prison. Each man received a five-year sentence with three to four years suspended, leaving one to two years of firm imprisonment. Prosecutors had asked for firm sentences of four, five and six years. According to the BBC, the three men will never again be allowed to wear the police uniform.
The 2020 arrest and the false report
The beating took place on 21 November 2020 at the entrance of Michel Zecler's music studio in Paris, during the Covid-19 lockdown. The officers had first wanted to check him for not wearing a mask, according to RTS. Musicians came up from the basement and pushed the officers back, after which the police broke a window and threw a tear gas grenade into the studio. Nine young people inside were detained along with Zecler, and he was struck again in the street. An intervention involving 30 officers as reinforcements followed. The three officers then drew up a report saying Zecler had violently resisted, and filed a complaint against him for rebellion.
Video evidence and the racism finding
Surveillance footage from the studio contradicted the officers' account. According to the BBC, Zecler absorbed about thirty punches, kicks and baton blows while offering almost no resistance. The same reporting says that without the camera he could have ended up in court as a potential criminal rather than a victim. Zecler said he had been called a racist insult during the attack, while the officers and their defence denied it and complained that racism had become the symbol of the trial. The court nonetheless recognised the racist aggravating circumstance, finding Zecler's account 'verifiable' in contrast to the officers'. For Zecler, who RTS says is still deeply affected six years on, that recognition was crucial.
Apologies and reactions
In their final words to the court, the three defendants, one of them in tears, apologised again to Zecler and to the civil parties. One of them said he wanted to apologise to the justice system and for the image he had given of the police. Zecler's lawyer said the law had prevailed and that the man's dignity had been restored, allowing him to make a fresh start, according to De Morgen. President Emmanuel Macron had called the case a 'shame' when it first came to light in 2020. Police institutions and unions had described the violence as isolated acts, while victims and researchers consider violence and racism in the police to be systemic.
The trial and public attention
Before the verdict, the prosecution asked the court to find a racist motive and to impose prison sentences, according to Mediapart. The courtroom stayed full throughout the hearings, with many racialised people attending in the hope that justice would finally be done. Mediapart reported that the racist nature of the attack ran through the debates for much of the trial. De Morgen noted that the case reignited the debate on violence and racism within the French police.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Courrier internationalMichel Zecler, UK-EU agreements, Denmark-Russia tensions, Trump on the loose: the night's newsMichel Zecler, accords RU-UE, tensions Danemark-Russie, Trump en roue libre : les informations de la nuit · original in French
- De MorgenThree French officers sentenced to years in prison for beating Black music producerDrie Franse agenten jarenlang de cel in wegens slaan zwarte muziekproducer · original in Dutch
- rts.chRacist violence: three French police officers receive prison sentencesViolences racistes : trois policiers français écopent de prison · original in French
- Le Monde.frPolice beating of Black music producer: Court recognizes racist nature of violence, sentences officers to prison, raising hopes for new legal precedent
- Michel Zecler
- Music producer who was beaten by three police officers at his Paris studio in 2020
- Aurélien Lapersonne
- One of the three police officers sentenced by the Paris criminal court
- Philippe Tondeux
- One of the three police officers sentenced by the Paris criminal court
- Pierre Plantier
- One of the three police officers sentenced by the Paris criminal court
- Emmanuel Macron
- President of France who called the 2020 case a shame
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar