Safety · Paris
Prosecutors seek 4 to 6 years for three officers in Michel Zecler beating trial
On Thursday, 19 November, the prosecutor asked the Paris criminal court for six, five and four years in prison for the three officers, plus a permanent ban on policing. The verdict is expected later on Friday, 20 November.
AI text based on reports by La Libre.be, Le Monde.fr, RTBF and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On Thursday, 19 November, prosecutors asked for six years for Aurélien Lapersonne, five for Philippe Tondeux and four for Pierre Plantier, plus a permanent ban on working as police officers.
The racist aggravating circumstance was set aside by the investigation for lack of evidence, but the court is to examine it during deliberation.
The three men gave their final words on Friday morning, 20 November, and the verdict is expected later that day. They face up to 15 years in prison.
Surveillance footage from the studio contradicted the officers' false police report, and Al Jazeera reports they are accused of striking Zecler 29 times in four minutes.
- 21 NovThree officers beat Michel Zecler in his Paris studio
- 19 NovProsecutors request four to six years in prison
- 20 NovVerdict expected later in the day
The 2020 arrest
On 21 November 2020, three police officers stopped Michel Zecler at the entrance of his Paris music studio, initially to check him for not wearing a mask during the Covid-19 period. The intervention escalated quickly: about 30 officers were sent as reinforcements and a tear gas grenade was thrown into the studio. Nine young people inside were also detained, and Zecler was beaten again in the street. The three officers then drew up a false police report accusing him of violence against them and filed a complaint against him for rebellion. Studio surveillance footage, which shows blows raining down on him with no retaliation, contradicted that version.
Prosecution requests
On Thursday, 19 November, the prosecutor asked the Paris criminal court for six years in prison for Aurélien Lapersonne, 29, five years for Philippe Tondeux, 50, and four years for Pierre Plantier, 37. She also asked for the racist aggravating circumstance to be applied, a point the investigation had set aside for lack of evidence, and for a permanent ban on working as a police officer. A deferred committal order, meaning imprisonment at a later date, was requested as well. Her submission lasted more than two hours. The three men face charges of violence and forging a public document, which carry up to 15 years in prison. A representative of the public prosecutor's office put it bluntly in a statement:
“There is no room for a symbolic sentence.”
- Aurélien Lapersonne
- 6 years
- Philippe Tondeux
- 5 years
- Pierre Plantier
- 4 years
Data from the article text
Racism and the defence
Zecler says the officers called him a racist slur several times during the beating, while the accused and their lawyers deny this categorically. The defence acknowledged that Zecler suffered inadmissible violence but rejected any racist dimension and challenged the severity of the sentences sought. Zecler's lawyer, Serge Money, asked the court for a verdict that gives a voice to victims of police violence. Legal scholar Rim-Sarah Alouane, of the University of Toulouse Capitole, told Al Jazeera that the case is about institutional racism and that falsified reports undermine the whole system.
“When these reports are falsified, we're questioning the integrity of the entire system.”
Testimony and the wider debate
Over three hours on the second day of the trial, Zecler described how the attack affected his personal and professional life and his difficulty at not being believed, particularly about racism. He told the court that without the footage he would not be there as a victim.
“Without these videos, I would not be standing before you as a victim.”
At the time, President Emmanuel Macron called the case a shame. Victims and researchers describe racism and violence in the police as systemic, while the institution and police unions see isolated acts.
Verdict expected on 20 November
The three men gave their final words on Friday morning, 20 November, and the court is expected to rule later that day. The racist aggravating circumstance, set aside by the investigation, will be examined during deliberation. Zecler has said that recognition of the racist dimension would be a relief. Key dates run from the attack in 2020 to the expected verdict.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- La Libre.beSix years after the assault on Michel Zecler, verdict for three police officersSix ans après l'agression de Michel Zecler, verdict pour trois policiers · original in French
- Le Monde.fr“If we accept that three police officers lie, the social bond is broken”: firm prison sentence requested at the trial of the violent arrest of Michel Zecler" Si l'on accepte que trois policiers mentent, le lien social est rompu " : prison ferme requise au procès de l'interpellation violente de Michel Zecler · original in French
- RTBFFour to six years requested against the police officers judged for the assault on Michel ZeclerQuatre à six ans requis contre les policiers jugés pour l'agression de Michel Zecler · original in French
- Al Jazeera OnlineFrance awaits verdict six years after police beat Black music producer
- Emmanuel Macron
- French president who called the case a shame in 2020
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar