Diplomacy · Geneva
UN talks on killer robots end with a pledge for rules within two years
Talks on lethal autonomous weapons in Geneva closed on Saturday, 21 November, after running past midnight. Russia's objection to observers had blocked the agenda since Monday, 16 November.
AI text based on reports by The Independent, Deutsche Welle, newsORF.at and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Around 100 states backed legally binding rules, while the United States, Russia and Israel opposed them. The agreed pledge to develop new rules within two years leaves open whether future measures will bind.
Moscow objected to observer participation, especially by the European Union, which kept the conference in informal consultations until the agenda stalled. The conference decides by consensus, so the objection worked like a veto.
A draft agreement seen by AFP would open negotiations on a 'framework protocol' codifying applicable international humanitarian law for autonomous weapons.
- 16 NovTalks open in Geneva, but Russia's objection to observers blocks adoption of the agenda
- 20 NovTarget for agreeing a negotiating mandate by Friday evening; no agreement in sight
- Past midnight, 21 NovemberTalks run into Saturday without a deal on negotiations
- 21 NovConference closes with a pledge to develop new rules within two years, binding status left open
Talks close with a pledge, not a binding rule
The UN talks on lethal autonomous weapons systems in Geneva closed on Saturday, 21 November, after running past midnight. The 128 states parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons had aimed to agree on the principle, modalities and duration of possible negotiations by Friday, 20 November. Instead, they pledged further talks to develop new rules within two years. The outcome was weakened by opposition from Russia and left open whether any future measures will be legally binding. Around 100 states backed a binding instrument, but big arms-producing nations, including the United States, Russia and Israel, opposed it. Rights groups had hoped for legally binding rules on a short timeframe, and the result fell short of that.
Russia blocked the agenda from the first day
Talks were obstructed from their opening on Monday, 16 November, before the agenda was even adopted. Moscow objected to the participation of observers, especially from the European Union, and a Russian delegate said openly that the aim was to limit their right to speak. Because the conference works by consensus, that objection functioned as a veto. Without an agreed agenda, work continued only through informal consultations. Brazil's ambassador, Frederico Meyer, told reporters that some countries hold the power while others hold the majority, and that the task now was to find a solution. He said the talks could not end empty-handed, since a failure would be terrible for humanity and the United Nations.
Diverging views on human control
The International Committee of the Red Cross, which oversees compliance with international humanitarian law, has pressed states to act. Its president, Mirjana Spoljaric, said:
“The states bear the decisive responsibility for ensuring that the future of peacekeeping is not handed over to machines.”
The campaign Stop Killer Robots says autonomous systems have already been used or tested, especially since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and its global coalition counts more than 300 organisations. Thomas Küchenmeister, the campaign's spokesperson for Germany, questioned what human control means in practice:
“If soldiers have only seconds left to check whether an AI-suggested course of action really respects international humanitarian law, that is probably hardly the case.”
He cited Lavender, an AI-supported targeting system developed in Israel. Helsing says its Clarity system, which proposes targets from analysed military data, keeps humans in control.
What the outcome leaves open
Early on Saturday the UN said in a brief statement that private consultations on the mandate and modalities of a future Group of Governmental Experts on lethal autonomous weapons systems were under way. A diplomat speaking on condition of anonymity said delegations had moved closer together over the week, with only one delegation still actively opposing the opening of negotiations. A draft agreement seen by AFP would open negotiations on a 'framework protocol' that codifies the applicable international humanitarian law for autonomous weapons. Whether any resulting measures would be binding remains unresolved in the outcome adopted on Saturday.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The IndependentStates seek to develop new rules to regulate 'killer robots' by 2028
- Deutsche WelleUN extends complex negotiations on “killer robots”ONU prolonga complejas negociaciones sobre "robots asesinos" · original in Spanish
- newsORF.at“Killer robots”: No agreement yet at UN talks"Killerroboter": Bisher keine Einigung bei UNO-Gesprächen · original in German
- La Libre.beUncertainty at the UN conference on “killer robots”Incertitude à la conférence de l'ONU sur les "robots tueurs" · original in French
- Mirjana Spoljaric
- President of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), who called on states to keep decisions about peacekeeping out of machines' hands
- Frederico Meyer
- Brazilian ambassador at the Geneva talks on lethal autonomous weapons
- Places
- Geneva, Russia, United States
- Organizations
- United Nations
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar