Conflicts · Geneva and Madrid

128 states meet in Geneva from 16 November to decide on killer robot curbs

The review conference of the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons opens in Geneva on Monday, 16 November, with a decision on talks due by Friday, 20 November. Whether states agree to launch treaty negotiations on lethal autonomous weapons is still open.

AI text based on reports by SWI swissinfo.ch, Handelsblatt, Der Tagesspiegel and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Geneva, Madrid · Switzerland, Spain
How it came to this
  1. 2013Discussion of autonomous weapons under the CCW begins, according to the Austrian foreign ministry
  2. Early February, MadridReaim summit: about a third of more than 80 participating states agree a closing declaration
  3. 16 NovCCW review conference opens in Geneva with 128 states parties
  4. 20 NovConference is due to reach its decision on negotiations by Friday

What is on the table

The review conference of the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) opens in Geneva on Monday, 16 November, with all 128 states parties taking part. Over five days, delegates will decide whether to start a first step toward a framework treaty on lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS), meaning systems that identify, select and attack targets without human control. The decision is due by Friday, 20 November, and a framework treaty could then take up to two years to draft. Whether any future agreement would be legally binding is still open, and the outcome could be a negotiating mandate that leaves that question unanswered. The Convention's five existing additional protocols are binding only on the states that have ratified them, and Germany is among those.

Where the divide lies

Germany and many other states want a ban on fully autonomous weapons that are entirely beyond human control, along with clear rules for systems that have some autonomous functions. The United States and other states developing such weapons oppose a ban. Decisions under the Convention are taken by consensus, so every state holds a veto, and diplomats are not optimistic about the outcome. An unnamed negotiator is cited as saying that the United States and Russia do not accept being bound, especially on new weapons systems. At the UN General Assembly, the United States, Russia, Belarus, North Korea and Israel spoke against opening negotiations, while 163 states warned of humanitarian and security risks and called for rapid international regulation.

Mauro Gilli, professor of military strategy at the Hertie School in Berlin, is skeptical that a deal will be reached.

“Of course we cannot rule out an agreement, but I am fundamentally skeptical.”

Mauro Gilli

Pressure from the UN and the Red Cross

Before the conference, UN Secretary-General António Guterres and Mirjana Spoljaric, president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, called for serious treaty negotiations on killer robots. They warned that the world is dangerously close to crossing a moral red line, with machines selecting and targeting humans on their own. Laurent Gisel, a lawyer at the ICRC, says time is short because experts consider it only a matter of time before fully autonomous systems are ready for use.

“If guardrails are not set now, it will become difficult: once something has been developed, it becomes much harder to put the genie back in the bottle.”

Laurent Gisel

There is also concern that once such weapons are developed, they could fall into the hands of militias, terrorist groups or criminal gangs.

Battlefield use and parallel efforts

UN experts in Geneva say there is no evidence yet that such weapons have been used in conflicts. Drones in Ukraine and Sudan are generally flown by pilots, some controlling them from hundreds of kilometres away. In the US missile strike on a school in Minab, Iran, in February, which killed more than 100 schoolchildren, experts say AI played a role in selecting the target, but the attack order came from humans. Israel uses AI-supported systems for target selection in Gaza, and its army denies using fully autonomous lethal weapons. Outside the UN, the Reaim initiative has brought governments, international organisations, civil society, academics and defence firms together since 2023. Its Madrid summit in early February saw only about a third of more than 80 participating states agree a closing declaration, with the United States and China not among them. Russia was not invited to Reaim and rejects the initiative.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar