Safety · Columbia and Union
Susan Smith denied parole a second time over her sons' 1994 drownings
The South Carolina parole board on Thursday, 19 November, voted 6-0 to refuse Susan Smith's release, 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in a lake in 1994.
AI text based on reports by Washington Post, SAPO and The Independent. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The South Carolina parole board voted 6-0 on Thursday, 19 November, to deny parole to Susan Smith, 55, who was first refused in 2024.
David Smith testified at the hearing and said setting her free would be a huge injustice, 32 years after the drownings in 1994.
Official agency statistics show the board approves parole in 4% of cases before it, and release required two-thirds support from the seven-member board.
- October 1994Smith tells the public a Black man stole her car with the boys inside, starting a nine-day search
- November 1994Smith confesses to drowning her two sons
- 2024Parole board unanimously rejects her first parole application
- 19 NovParole board unanimously denies her second application by a 6-0 vote
The board's decision
The South Carolina parole board on Thursday, 19 November, unanimously denied parole to Susan Smith, now 55, by a 6-0 vote. Smith was convicted of killing her two young sons in 1994 by strapping them into car seats and rolling her car into John D. Long Lake in Union County. The boys were aged 3 and 14 months when they died. Smith first sought parole in 2024, when she became eligible after serving 30 years, and the board rejected that request as well. Release required two-thirds support from the seven-member board, so Thursday's refusal was her second. Under the South Carolina rules that applied to her case, a denial is followed by another review every two years.
The 1994 case
In October 1994, Smith told the public that a Black man had stolen her car at a traffic light with her two sons inside. She insisted on that account for nine days while a search operation ran. The claim was false, and it drew on a centuries-old racist trope that framed Black men as a danger to white women. In November 1994 she confessed to drowning the boys. A jury later rejected the death penalty, and she was sentenced to life in prison.
Testimony before the board
Smith appeared on video from prison and addressed the board directly. She told members that she had changed.
“I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago. I have changed. I have grown up. I have matured.”
She also spoke of deep remorse over the unbearable pain she caused. David Smith, the boys' father, attended in person after making an early morning trip to Columbia with the original trial prosecutors to ask that she stay in prison. He wore a picture of his sons on his suit lapel and fought back tears as he testified. He said that 32 years may seem a long time to others, but for him it feels as if he buried the boys only a short while ago.
“She did that deliberately. It wasn't an accident; it wasn't a mistake.”
He told the board that setting her free would be a huge injustice.
Why the odds stay low
Official agency statistics show the board approves parole in just 4% of cases before it, and most of the grants involve non-violent offenses. Smith's case is among the most notorious to reach the panel. The false claims that Smith made in 1994 were made by a white woman, and they continue to be discussed as a case about racial fear. State prosecutors have long asserted that she killed her sons because she believed they had caused the wealthy son of her employer to end their romantic affair. Smith remains in prison under her life sentence.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Washington PostSusan Smith denied parole 32 years after drowning sons in S.C. lake
- SAPOSentenced to life in prison for the death of her children in 1994, she sees her request for freedom refused for the second timeCondenada a prisão perpétua pela morte dos filhos em 1994, vê pedido de liberdade recusado pela segunda vez · original in Portuguese
- The IndependentSusan Smith denied parole request after ex-husband's tearful plea to keep her in jail
- David Smith
- Father of the two boys, who testified against his former wife's release at the parole hearing
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar