Diplomacy · Berlin, Shenzhen, and Brussels

Coalition of the Willing convenes in Berlin on 19 November over Ukraine security guarantees

Leaders of the Coalition of the Willing meet in Berlin on 19 November to set out post-war security guarantees for Ukraine, while Europe still disputes who should talk to Russia.

AI text based on reports by POLITICO, ANSA.it and Open. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Berlin, Shenzhen, Brussels · Germany, China, Belgium
How it came to this
  1. 2 MarCoalition of the Willing begins, days after the Oval Office clash between Trump, Vance and Zelenskyy
  2. 19 NovCoalition of the Willing summit in Berlin
  3. 23 NovForeign ministers meet on Austria's 15-point paper

Berlin summit and the new five-nation format

The Coalition of the Willing meets in Berlin on 19 November, at the Chancellery, to discuss the evolution of negotiations to end the war and the security guarantees Ukraine needs once the fighting stops. ANSA puts the number of participating countries at 37, while POLITICO counts more than 35. Friedrich Merz, Emmanuel Macron and Andy Burnham, the three co-chairs known as the E3, will preside. Their track covers military security and planning a multinational deterrence force on the ground in post-conflict Ukraine. Italy and Poland join the E3 in a five-nation format called E5, which makes its debut in Berlin and sets the political strategy and common diplomatic line for talks with the United States and Russia. Rome has said it will not contribute troops, a position the Italian government repeated in the hours before the summit.

Envoys and the Shenzhen track

Zelenskyy is also due at the table, where the E3 and E5 will interface with the American envoys. Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, who did not travel to China, are expected in Germany instead. Kremlin economic adviser Kirill Dmitriev said the two are working with European partners and presenting them with a possible European security structure. The talks in Shenzhen shape the mood in Berlin, where Donald Trump and Xi Jinping are scheduled for bilateral talks on Thursday, 19 November, ahead of a three-way meeting with Vladimir Putin. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte has argued in recent days that Kyiv must be supported to get through the winter and to negotiate from as strong a position as possible.

Who speaks for Europe

EU leaders settled on a negotiating team made up of France, Germany, Italy and Poland, plus the United Kingdom and the top representatives of NATO, the European Commission and the Council. Kaja Kallas, the EU's foreign policy chief, is not part of it. Open reports that Russia and Israel refuse to talk with her, and that Israel cut its channels with her after reports that she compared Israeli policy toward Palestinians with South African apartheid. Kallas, speaking in Dublin on 13 November, argued that member states had named her in 2024 and that her firm stance on Ukraine should qualify her for the seat.

The debate has moved from who represents Europe to what it should demand. Kallas wants the Europeans to start by asking for as much as possible, while Austria prefers a looser approach built on confidence-building measures. Austria's foreign minister Beate Meinl-Reisinger tabled a 15-point paper ahead of the foreign ministers' meeting on Monday, 23 November, proposing limited or partial ceasefires and an international forum to monitor any peace deal. In her words:

“Now, the focus must shift from the 'who' to the 'what'”

Beate Meinl-Reisinger, austrian foreign minister behind the 15-point paper

Norway, which sits outside the team but has direct contacts with Russia, points to the 1975 Helsinki Accords as a model for managing extreme tensions. Espen Barth Eide, Norway's foreign minister, said:

“There's a range of things that Europe should make clear that it's not ready to discuss.”

Espen Barth Eide, norwegian foreign minister urging Cold War-style arms deals

Domestic pressure and the funding question

Merz barely kept his job this autumn after a surge in support for far-right populists, which he admitted was an electoral 'disaster' for his Christian Democrats. Macron has long been unpopular, and his centrist allies face a wipeout in next year's presidential race, where Marine Le Pen is gaining support. Burnham is the only co-chair with a solid majority in parliament, but he took over from Keir Starmer in July without winning a general election and has mostly focused on domestic policy. The coalition itself began on 2 March 2025, days after Trump and JD Vance attacked Zelenskyy in the Oval Office.

Funding is the other front. Berlin wants a headroom arrangement that would give the EU room to fund Ukraine beyond the €100 billion the Commission proposed for its next seven-year budget, according to a senior European official. An EU diplomat said that under the German plan, future borrowing decisions would need only a qualified majority rather than unanimity, making it harder for a single government to block support. The plan is designed to keep money flowing even if Le Pen wins the April vote in France and follows through on her pledge to cut support to Kyiv, a scenario the senior official said would make Ukraine funding even more disputed.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Organizations
European Union

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar