Government · Warsaw and Strasbourg

Strasbourg court rejects Święczkowski and Sochański bid over Polish Constitutional Tribunal

The European Court of Human Rights unanimously refused an interim measure sought by Bogdan Święczkowski and Bartłomiej Sochański, the suspended president and vice-president of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal. The refusal was announced on 17 November, and Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek criticized the bid as hypocritical.

AI text based on reports by TVP Info, rmf24.pl, www.gazetaprawna.pl and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Warsaw, Strasbourg · Poland, France
How it came to this
  1. 30 OctKorwin-Piotrowska takes over the tribunal and orders a pause in the duties of Święczkowski and Sochański
  2. 12 NovŚwięczkowski and Sochański apply to the ECtHR for an interim measure
  3. 16 NovPolish government submits explanations to the court
  4. 17 NovECtHR unanimously refuses the interim measure, the refusal is announced

Strasbourg declines interim relief

The European Court of Human Rights has refused a request for an interim measure filed by Bogdan Święczkowski and Bartłomiej Sochański, the suspended president and vice-president of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maciej Wewiór said the court informed the Polish government of the refusal and that a panel of seven judges reached the decision unanimously. The two men applied to the court on 12 November, and the judges weighed explanations the Polish government submitted on 16 November. The court concluded that the applicants had not shown a direct risk of irreparable harm to their rights under Article 6 of the Convention, which covers the right to a fair trial.

Justice minister's reaction

Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek responded on X on the afternoon of 17 November, writing that Święczkowski had for years claimed European courts were bad, had nothing to say in Poland and did not deserve to be called independent courts. Żurek recalled that in May Święczkowski had disregarded an interim measure from the Strasbourg court that ordered Sejm-elected judges admitted to adjudication. He also noted that in August, as a former head of the Internal Security Agency (ABW), Święczkowski told TV Republika he had information from inside the court that undermined its judges' independence. In Żurek's account, the picture changed once the blocking of the Constitutional Tribunal ended on 30 October, after which the Strasbourg court suddenly seemed less frightening. He summed up his view in a single line.

“Hypocrisy has short legs.”

Waldemar Żurek, polish Minister of Justice

Deputy Justice Minister Dariusz Mazur wrote on X that Święczkowski had tried to use the court as 'a last plank of rescue', thereby recognizing its status as an independent and impartial body. He added, ironically, that life writes the best scenarios.

Background to the suspension

On 30 October, representatives of the group of judges elected to the tribunal in the current Sejm term said that Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, as the longest-serving judge, had taken over leadership of the tribunal and ordered a pause in the duties of Święczkowski and Sochański. In early November, a meeting convened by Korwin-Piotrowska was attended by eight Sejm-elected judges: three who had taken their oaths from President Karol Nawrocki at the Presidential Palace and five who swore in at the Sejm using the formula 'before the president'. The changes and the way they were introduced are contested, with the political right arguing that the governing side staged a coup, while some experts openly question the legal basis for the steps taken. Wirtualna Polska reported, citing an unnamed tribunal source, that the two sought a stay of ongoing proceedings. The outlet also noted that Święczkowski had earlier ignored an ECtHR interim measure ordering him to take on four judges whose oaths the president had not accepted.

Immunity vote

The tribunal's General Assembly of judges was convened on 17 November to vote on motions to lift the immunities of Święczkowski and Sochański. Wirtualna Polska first reported the Strasbourg refusal on an unofficial basis, and the foreign ministry and justice minister later confirmed it. The sources do not report the outcome of the immunity vote.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar