Diplomacy · Moscow
Russia's billionaires privately call Putin 'Ded' and plan for a post-Putin future
Russian billionaires who stayed silent when Putin summoned them in February 2022 are now discussing Russia without him, according to a BBC report. Forbes counts 155 Russian billionaires, the most in the country's history.
AI text based on reports by NEWS 24/7, TVP Info, Il Messaggero and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On 24 February 2022, more than three dozen billionaires sat in the Kremlin's Yekaterininsky Hall while Putin asked for their support. None of the invited billionaires spoke in the video the Kremlin published.
In 2003, Mikhail Khodorkovsky accused Putin of corruption. He was convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement, spent 10 years in prison and denied the charges.
Arkady Ostrovsky of The Economist says a political shift is under way in how the ultra-rich view the country's future. Some elites are asking whether Russia could return to the 1990s.
Forbes counts 155 Russian billionaires, with combined wealth of close to $700 billion. Sanctions over the war restrict their travel and the way they spend their money.
Aleksandra Prokopienko says tycoons once called Putin 'Nachalnik' or 'Pervyi' but now privately use 'Ded', meaning grandfather or old man.
- 2003Khodorkovsky accuses Putin of corruption and is later jailed for 10 years
- 24 FebPutin convenes the richest businessmen at the Kremlin hours after the invasion of Ukraine
- 16 NovBBC reports that oligarchs are imagining Russia after Putin
A meeting held in silence
Hours after the full-scale invasion of Ukraine began on 24 February 2022, Vladimir Putin, who is 74, gathered Russia's richest men in the Kremlin's Yekaterininsky Hall. More than three dozen of them sat along one wall, many wearing face masks because of the Covid pandemic. Putin sat on the opposite side of the room, leaving a wide gap between himself and the businessmen, and he did not wear a mask. The Kremlin released a video of the meeting, and none of the invited billionaires said a word in it. In coded language, Putin said he expected them to back the war.
“I would like to call on you to show understanding of what is going on.”
He then asked the businessmen to work with the government to find tools that would support production, the economy and jobs.
The price of dissent
That silence reflects what Russia's wealthiest have learned under Putin's rule. In 2003, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, then the country's richest man and a funder of opposition groups, accused Putin of presiding over rampant corruption. Khodorkovsky was convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement and spent the next 10 years behind bars, a warning to other would-be critics. He denied the charges. Some tycoons are said to have objected to the war, but they have tended to keep those views to themselves.
Murmurs of a post-Putin future
Beneath that silence, some members of the once-powerful business elite are imagining Russia after Putin. The BBC reports they are asking whether the country could slide back to the 1990s, when oligarchs enjoyed the fruits of power, or whether a healthier politics could take root. Arkady Ostrovsky, a Kremlin watcher at The Economist, says he feels a political shift is under way in how the ultra-rich view the country's future. Ostrovsky reached that view after spending hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men. Aleksandra Prokopienko, a Russian journalist and analyst living in exile, says the mood is changing and that tycoons now refer to Putin as 'Ded', meaning grandfather or old man, with contempt rather than respect.
Wealth they cannot spend freely
The fortunes of these men have grown even as their room to act has shrunk. Forbes counts 155 Russian billionaires, the most in the country's history, with a combined fortune of close to $700 billion. Sanctions imposed over the war in Ukraine have stripped many of them of their international status. They can no longer move freely by private jet, enjoy yachts on the Côte d'Azur or spend time in their luxury villas as before.
No organised challenge yet
For now, there are no signs of an organised plan against the Russian president. Fear of the consequences of open confrontation still deters even those who appear dissatisfied with the current situation. Dissatisfaction therefore stays largely private, voiced in conversations and nicknames rather than in public statements. The 2022 meeting shows how the Kremlin still expects loyalty from the country's richest men, and fear of open confrontation still deters even those who look dissatisfied.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- NEWS 24/7Oligarchs sharpen their knives: What they plan for Russia after PutinΟι ολιγάρχες ακονίζουν τα μαχαίρια τους: Τι σχεδιάζουν για τη Ρωσία μετά τον Πούτιν · original in Greek
- TVP InfoHe was “the boss”, today he is “the old man”. Oligarchs plan life after PutinBył "naczelnikiem", dziś jest "dziadem". Oligarchowie planują życie po Putinie · original in Polish
- Il MessaggeroRussia, billionaire oligarchs privately call Putin “the grandfather”. And they are already imagining a future without him"Russia, gli oligarchi miliardari nel privato chiamano Putin "il nonno". E immaginano già un futuro senza di lui" · original in Italian
- NewsITBBC: Russian tycoons plan the post-Putin eraBBC: Ρώσοι κροίσοι σχεδιάζουν τη μετά-Πούτιν εποχή - Τα τρία σενάρια · original in Greek
- Vladimir Putin
- Russian president who gathered the country's richest men at the Kremlin on 24 February 2022
- Mikhail Khodorkovsky
- Former Russian oil magnate who accused Putin of corruption in 2003 and was jailed for 10 years
- Arkady Ostrovsky
- Journalist and Kremlin watcher at The Economist who says a political shift is under way among the ultra-rich
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar