Government · Lisbon
Portuguese parliament orders public broadcaster RTP to air bullfights in 2027
The Chega proposal passed during the specialty debate on the 2027 State Budget on Wednesday, 18 November, with PSD and CDS-PP support. RTP workers call the move political interference in editorial decisions.
AI text based on reports by Notícias ao Minuto, PÚBLICO and SIC Notícias. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On Wednesday, 18 November, parliament approved the Chega proposal during the specialty debate on the 2027 State Budget, with PSD, CDS-PP and Chega in favour.
The text obliges RTP to broadcast bullfighting shows on its television channels during 2027, although the broadcaster had already stopped airing them.
RTP's workers' committees called the vote an attack on editorial autonomy, citing the Television Law and the concession contract, while the left called it a civilisational setback.
Parliament approves the proposal
Portugal's parliament approved a proposal from the Chega party that requires public broadcaster RTP to air bullfights. The vote took place on Wednesday, 18 November, during the specialty debate on the 2027 State Budget. PSD, CDS-PP and Chega voted in favour, while the Liberal Initiative, PAN and the parliamentary left voted against. The Socialist Party had abstained at committee stage but switched to opposition in the plenary, which did not change the result. PAN moved the proposal from committee to the plenary floor.
The text says that during 2027 RTP must broadcast bullfighting shows on its television channels as part of its public service duties under the current concession contract, describing them as part of Portugal's popular cultural heritage. RTP had already stopped airing bullfights, in line with other international public service broadcasters.
Government declines to comment
Minister of the Presidency António Leitão Amaro, who oversees RTP, refused to comment on the decision and said he never pronounces himself on the broadcaster's editorial matters. Asked whether political power had interfered with the channel, he pointed to earlier questions about cartoons and bullfights that he had also declined to answer. He said the state takes part in drawing up RTP's public service contract and that it is normal for parliament, as the representative of the people, to speak freely. He added that he believes RTP has a culture of independence.
“On those questions, concerning RTP's editorial options, I have consistently refused to pronounce myself.”
RTP workers call it political interference
The editorial committee of RTP's workers and the Porto workers' subcommittee called the vote an attack on the broadcaster's autonomy and a 'stuffy' intrusion by political power. They argued that it clashes with the Television Law, which guarantees freedom of programming and bars sovereign bodies from forcing or blocking specific broadcasts, and with a concession contract that enshrines editorial independence. They also pointed to developments in animal-protection law and to individual rights, including freedom of conscience in the constitution. They warned that bullfights are only the start and that any content a party chooses could follow.
“A parliamentary imposition does not eliminate the rights of those who work at RTP, nor does it exempt the company from hearing and weighing its professionals' concerns.”
Heated chamber debate
The debate was heated enough that acting parliament president Rodrigo Saraiva asked that the plenary not be turned into a bullfight, even though that was the subject. PAN's sole deputy, Inês Sousa Real, said the approval smelled of Estado Novo and that more than 70% of Portuguese do not want bullfighting. The left called the proposal a 'civilisational setback' and an attempt at political interference, while the CDS-PP invoked 'cultural freedom'. Socialist deputy Porfírio Silva said the issue was one of freedom and that parliament should avoid substituting itself for RTP. A brief exchange over a remark about Cristina Rodrigues, a former PAN member now in Chega, prompted a request to speak from Chega parliamentary leader Pedro Pinto.
Open legal questions
A PÚBLICO opinion column argued that article 26 of the Television Law expressly limits the power of sovereign bodies to impose the broadcast of programmes. The author said the proposal raises legal doubts that cannot be ignored, although any possible unconstitutionality must be assessed by the competent bodies. The column also argued that the existence of a practice in a society does not by itself justify public institutions promoting it. The workers said they would take their concerns further.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Notícias ao MinutoBullfights on RTP? Workers denounce “stuffy intrusion”Touradas na RTP? Trabalhadores denunciam "bafienta intromissão" · original in Portuguese
- PÚBLICOBullfight on RTP: editorial independence cannot be at the mercy of political powerTourada na RTP: a independência editorial não pode ficar à mercê do poder político · original in Portuguese
- Notícias ao MinutoBullfights on RTP? Leitão Amaro refuses to comment on parliamentary decisionTouradas na RTP? Leitão Amaro recusa comentar decisão parlamentar · original in Portuguese
- Notícias ao MinutoParliament confirms bullfights on RTP despite PS oppositionParlamento confirma touradas na RTP apesar da oposição do PS · original in Portuguese
- António Leitão Amaro
- Minister of the Presidency, who oversees RTP and declined to comment on the decision
- Inês Sousa Real
- Sole PAN deputy who condemned the vote and cited polling on bullfighting
- Rodrigo Saraiva
- Acting president of the Portuguese parliament who asked that the plenary not become a bullfight
- Pedro Pinto
- Chega parliamentary leader who requested to speak during the debate
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar