Government · Warsaw
Polish Supreme Court rules unpublished Constitutional Tribunal rulings bind before official publication
On Wednesday, 18 November, three combined chambers of the Supreme Court (SN) adopted a resolution holding that a Constitutional Tribunal (TK) ruling has binding force whether or not it has been published in the official journal.
AI text based on reports by wpolityce.pl, Rzeczpospolita and NIEZALEZNA.PL. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The three combined chambers of the Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday, 18 November, that a TK ruling has general binding force regardless of its announcement in the official journal, citing article 190(1) of the constitution.
A TK ruling counts only if it was issued by a panel made up solely of judges who took the oath in the presence of the President after their election by the Sejm.
More than 40 judges took part in the day-long sitting of the 63-judge combined chambers, and eight judges filed a separate opinion on the publication point.
Joanna Misztal-Konecka, president of the Civil Chamber, put three questions to the court, covering scope-limited rulings under article 401(1) of the Civil Procedure Code, binding force before publication, and the start of the three-month retrial deadline.
The resolution
On Wednesday, 18 November, three combined chambers of the Supreme Court (SN) adopted a resolution in the afternoon, after a full day of sittings. The chambers were the Civil, Labour and Social Insurance Chamber, and the Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber. Over 40 judges took part, and Rzeczpospolita reported that the combined chambers number 63 judges. The resolution answered three questions put by Joanna Misztal-Konecka, president of the Civil Chamber, which concerned among other things the binding force of TK rulings that were not published in the last two years.
Binding force without publication
The resolution states that a TK ruling is a decision issued in a matter within the Tribunal's competence, after the procedure set by law, by a panel made up solely of people who took their oath before the President of the Republic, in his presence, after their election by the Sejm. Under article 190(1) of the constitution, such a ruling has general binding force regardless of its announcement in the official journal. Rzeczpospolita put the number of unpublished TK rulings at 85. Eight judges filed a separate opinion on the publication point.
The judges and the questions
Judge Aleksander Stępkowski read out the reasoning and explained who may sit on TK panels. Panels may consist only of people who took the oath in the presence of the President, and he said the oath could in principle be taken remotely.
“In extraordinary situations, one can imagine that this will be remote presence through available means of communication.”
The first question asked whether a scope-limited TK ruling, which finds a provision unconstitutional only in part, is grounds for retrial under article 401(1) of the Civil Procedure Code. The second asked whether authorities must recognise and apply a TK ruling from the day it is announced by the Tribunal, before its publication in the official journal, and whether a retrial can be sought before publication. The third asked from which date the three-month deadline for seeking a retrial should run if the second question is answered positively. Rzeczpospolita reported that a quorum was reached despite the absence of judges it called the 'old judges'.
Composition of the chambers
According to NIEZALEZNA.PL, most of the more than 40 judges were appointed to the Supreme Court after 2017 through procedures before the National Council of the Judiciary (KRS). The resolution came in response to the request of Joanna Misztal-Konecka, whose three questions were answered in a single resolution adopted on the same day.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- wpolityce.plWhat a plot twist! The Supreme Court blew up the usurpers' entire planAleż zwrot akcji! SN wysadził w powietrze cały plan uzurpatorów · original in Polish
- RzeczpospolitaWhat about the 85 unpublished TK rulings? The Supreme Court issued an important resolutionCo z 85 nieopublikowanymi wyrokami TK? SN wydał ważną uchwałę · original in Polish
- NIEZALEZNA.PLThree chambers of the Supreme Court took a position on the TK. Key condition regarding judgesTrzy izby Sądu Najwyższego zajęły stanowisko w sprawie TK. Kluczowy warunek dotyczący sędziów · original in Polish
- Places
- Warsaw
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar