Government · London, Glasgow, and Bradford
Milburn NEET review sets 5% target by 2036 as UK minister presses Scotland
Alan Milburn's youth review calls for a 'complete system reset' and a cut in the NEET rate from 13% to 5% by 2036, putting welfare reform back on the new prime minister's agenda.
AI text based on reports by The Independent, inews.co.uk, LBC and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Almost one million 16-to-24-year-olds, or 13%, are NEET, and Alan Milburn's review sets a goal of 5% by 2036 through a 'complete system reset'.
The review proposes removing the health element of Universal Credit for under-25s, except in cases of profound disability, in its report published on Tuesday, 17 November.
Commentary cites an estimated £125 billion annual cost and a 140,000 rise in NEETs over a decade, while research found 61% of employers would hire a young person with no work history.
Helen MacNamara warned that delay lets MPs' doubt grow, and James Purnell, Burnham's chief of staff, started Universal Credit as work and pensions secretary.
Douglas Alexander said around one in six young Scots, about 90,000 people, are not in work, education or training, and many measures need Holyrood to adopt them.
What the review proposes
Alan Milburn's review of young people not in education, employment or training was published on Tuesday, 17 November, and calls for a 'complete system reset'. It puts almost one million 16-to-24-year-olds, or 13% of that group, in the NEET category and sets a goal of 5% by 2036. Proposals include removing the health element of Universal Credit for under-25s, except in cases of profound disability, and cutting National Insurance for young workers. The review also suggests doubling apprenticeships, shifting the curriculum towards work skills, and offering mental health support without a formal diagnosis. A Youth Opportunity Service would combine employment, careers, health and practical help across England.
- Latest rate in review
- 13 %
- 2036 target
- 5 %
Data from the article text
Political test for Burnham
Andy Burnham, the new prime minister, inherits the political risk that the MP rebellion over welfare reform created for Keir Starmer. Former special adviser Cleo Watson said Westminster insiders found the report very impressive but highly aspirational. Helen MacNamara, a former deputy cabinet secretary, expects it to be implemented, citing the pre-briefings and the absence of rival announcements as signs of Downing Street backing. She noted that James Purnell, Burnham's chief of staff, started Universal Credit while serving as work and pensions secretary. MacNamara warned that delay lets doubt grow among MPs, and parents may ask what 'profound' means for children with conditions such as ADHD. A Timms Review of PIP is due in the week of 23 November.
Employers and the cost of hiring
Commentary from the business side argues the plan will fail unless hiring becomes cheaper. It cites an estimated £125 billion annual cost of youth non-employment and a rise of 140,000 in the number of NEETs over a decade. Research in the piece found 61% of employers would hire a young person with no work history, and more than a third of recruiters named employer National Insurance as a main hurdle. The piece says a gradual cut for 21- to 24-year-olds does not go far enough, and it urges removing employer National Insurance for all under-25s. Government decisions are expected in the New Year, with legislation unlikely before the middle of 2027.
Scotland and devolved delivery
Scotland featured in the Commons exchange that followed publication. Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, said youth joblessness is a Scottish problem too and urged the Scottish Government to provide personalised local support. Answering a question from Labour MP Joani Reid, he said:
“It's really important that governments in all parts of the country take this seriously.”
Douglas Alexander, the Scottish Secretary, said around one in six young Scots, about 90,000 people, are neither working nor learning. Many proposals depend on Holyrood adopting them, because most of the relevant policy areas are devolved. McFadden also said the Prime Minister, the Chancellor and he had met Scottish and Welsh First Ministers in Glasgow in the weeks before the report.
Lived experience and the causes
A Guardian opinion piece by Mark Mon-Williams, a Leeds professor who supported Milburn with data analytics, argues the NEET problem reflects a neglected childhood crisis. He cites 4.5 million children living in poverty and a Bradford birth cohort that began in 2007 and has tracked 13,500 children. A first-person column by a 24-year-old graduate describes signing off Universal Credit in May and says many friends have left the UK. One friend, who moved to Warsaw in August after more than a year on Universal Credit, applied for over 300 roles and found a graduate role in Poland within three weeks. The column cites 981,000 Neets for April to June 2026.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The IndependentIs the Milburn report the 'real' ten-year plan?
- The IndependentMilburn report is 'staggeringly ambitious' - can Burnham pull it off?
- inews.co.ukAt 24, I have two degrees but can't find work - my friends are fleeing the UK
- LBCMilburn's plan will fail unless Burnham makes it cheaper for businesses to hire
- Alan Milburn
- Author of the government-commissioned review into young people not in education, employment or training
- Pat McFadden
- Secretary of State for Work and Pensions who spoke on Scotland in the Commons
- Andy Burnham
- New prime minister who must decide how to handle the review
- Keir Starmer
- Former prime minister whose government faced an MP rebellion over welfare reform
- Douglas Alexander
- Scottish Secretary who cited the one-in-six figure for Scotland
- Helen MacNamara
- Former deputy cabinet secretary and podcast host analysing the review
- James Purnell
- Burnham's chief of staff who started Universal Credit as DWP secretary
- Cleo Watson
- Former special adviser who co-hosts the In The Room podcast
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar