The San Isidro court fixed 22 December as the date for its verdict once the oral hearings ended on 22 October, after about six months of hearings.
Prosecutors asked for 12 years for neurosurgeon Leopoldo Luque and four to 12 years for six of the seven defendants. Civil parties asked for up to 16 years for some defendants.
Roberto Rallin rejected the foreseeability argument, while Francisco Oneto described an acute and unpredictable heart attack as the cause of death, a claim he repeated on 21 October.
Maradona's eldest daughter, Dalma Maradona, addressed the judges in tears at the close of the hearings, asking that her father receive justice like anyone else.
The oral hearings in the trial over the death of Diego Maradona have concluded, and the San Isidro court has set 22 December as the date for its verdict. Seven people, described as doctors, psychiatrists, psychologists and nurses, have been on trial since April, accused of negligence in the treatment of the former footballer while he was convalescing in a house he had rented. Maradona died on 25 November 2020 at the age of 60, two weeks after brain surgery for a subdural hematoma. An autopsy cited a heart attack and pulmonary oedema as the causes of death. The defendants deny the allegations.
Dalma Maradona, his eldest daughter, became overcome with tears during an unscheduled address to the judges at the close of the oral proceedings. She said the family had been forced to hear terrible things during the trial, and that they had known this could happen. She spoke with a broken voice as she asked that her father receive justice, like any other person, beyond the fact that he was Maradona. The court then communicated the date on which the verdict will be read.
Prosecutors have asked for a 12-year prison sentence for Leopoldo Luque, a 45-year-old neurosurgeon who was Maradona's trusted doctor and the main decision-maker on his medical team at the time of his death. For six of the seven defendants, they requested sentences between four and 12 years. Civil parties, including Maradona's children or sisters, asked for terms of up to 16 years for some defendants, among them Luque. Prosecutors criticised Luque's inaction, arguing that his approach had always been to do nothing in the face of warning signs such as heart failure and swelling. They relied on a medical commission the court set up in 2021, which found that Maradona's history of heart problems should have been taken into account.
Defence lawyer Roberto Rallin rejected the prosecution's argument that Maradona's death was foreseeable, and told the court that his client is innocent. He put the core of the defence plainly, saying Luque has been singled out for blame.
“Leopoldo Luque has been the scapegoat.”
Francisco Oneto, the other defence lawyer, maintained that the death followed an acute and unpredictable heart attack. Speaking on 21 October, Oneto insisted that the outcome could not have been anticipated.
“There was absolutely no possibility of predicting this fatal outcome.”
Luque's lawyers also challenged the conclusions of the interdisciplinary medical commission, which the court had established in 2021 to give an opinion on the death.
Maradona's death came during the COVID-19 pandemic and plunged Argentina into mourning. Tens of thousands of people defied social distancing rules to bid farewell to him while he lay in state at the presidential palace. He was found dead in his bed at the Tigre residence, north of Buenos Aires, which had been rented for his recovery. An earlier attempt to try the case collapsed in 2025 because a judge was biased, after she had secretly helped prepare a documentary series about the case. The current proceedings began in April and ran for about fifty hearings over six months.
The court will deliver its verdict on 22 December, a date set on 22 October at the end of the oral hearings. The ruling is meant to determine responsibility for Maradona's death. Until then, the seven defendants remain on trial and deny the charges, with the defence focused on the claim that the fatal heart attack could not have been foreseen.
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support PollarFootball · San Isidro and Tigre
Prosecutors want 12 years for neurosurgeon Leopoldo Luque, while the defence says he has been unfairly blamed. The San Isidro court will deliver its verdict on 22 December.
AI text based on reports by Süddeutsche Zeitung, Le Monde.fr, stern.de and other publishers. Published .