Safety · Bologna

Italy's top court makes life sentence final for Giampaolo Amato over 2021 poisonings

On 19 November Italy's Court of Cassation rejected the defence appeal and confirmed the life sentence of Giampaolo Amato, a former Virtus Bologna doctor, for the 2021 deaths of his wife and mother-in-law in Bologna.

AI text based on reports by Open, Mediafax.ro, ANSA.it and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Bologna · Italy
How it came to this
  1. April 2023Amato arrested by the carabinieri and held in custody
  2. 16 OctBologna Assise court finds him guilty and imposes life imprisonment
  3. 19 NovCourt of Cassation makes the life sentence final

The ruling

On Thursday, 19 November, the first criminal section of Italy's Court of Cassation rejected the defence's appeal and made final the life sentence imposed on Giampaolo Amato, a 66-year-old ophthalmologist and former doctor of the Virtus Bologna basketball club. The judges reached their decision after nearly seven hours of deliberation, accepting the request of the prosecutor general's office to dismiss the appeal. Amato had already received a life sentence at both earlier levels of the case, and he has been in custody since his arrest by the carabinieri in April 2023. He has always maintained his innocence and denied the charges concerning the deaths of his wife, a 62-year-old physician, and his 87-year-old mother-in-law in Bologna in 2021. Prosecutors say he used a combination of two drugs, sevoflurane and midazolam, to kill them.

The prosecution's account

Prosecutor general Simone Perelli, arguing the case before the Cassation judges, called the appeal ruling an unassailable decision and said guilt had been established beyond reasonable doubt. He then described the alleged plan in the following terms:

“The double murder, in the mind of whoever devised it, had to be perfect; he wanted to close his past by eliminating whoever could be an obstacle.”

Simone Perelli

According to the prosecution, the first death was a trial run. The 87-year-old mother-in-law was found dead in her bed in Bologna on 9 October 2021, and her death initially appeared to have natural causes. Twenty-two days later, on the morning of 31 October, the wife was found dead, having died overnight between 30 and 31 October. Amato was the one who found her, after his sister-in-law and friends, worried that she was not answering the phone, alerted him. The couple's son, Nicola, a doctor, asked for an autopsy on his mother out of fear of a hereditary congenital disease, and toxicology revealed sevoflurane and midazolam. Later testing on the exhumed body of the mother-in-law showed traces of the same substances. Prosecutors describe a dual motive: Amato's wish to live freely with a younger woman, and an economic interest in gaining possession of his wife's property.

Investigation and earlier verdicts

The first person to suspect something was wrong was the wife's sister, Anna Maria Linsalata, who is a civil party in the proceedings. She kept a bottle of wine that the wife had drunk together with her husband, and analysis of its contents became one of the key clues in the investigation. Amato was arrested by the carabinieri in April 2023, and on 16 October 2024 the Bologna Assise court found him guilty and sentenced him to life imprisonment, a verdict confirmed on appeal. The appeal judges described the killings as a repeated crime driven exclusively by selfish motives. The defence, through lawyers Franco Coppi and Valerio Spigarelli, has argued that the wife took the substances herself because she was dependent on medication, and that the traces found in the mother-in-law came from an operation she had undergone a few months earlier. The key dates are shown below.

The family's position

Nicola Amato, the couple's son and a doctor, defended his father in an interview with the Repubblica newspaper on the eve of the Cassation hearing. He said his father is innocent because there is no direct evidence against him and that the case should not be closed. He also said that he and his sister had not been under their father's control. Amato himself has maintained his innocence throughout the proceedings. Courts at all three levels have now upheld the conviction.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Bologna

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar