Diplomacy · Moscow, Brussels, and Abu Dhabi
Kremlin makes European role in Ukraine peace talks conditional on its stance
Moscow says European states must take a position on the peace process before joining talks, while Brussels says multilateral talks in Europe are possible but no venue has been discussed.
AI text based on reports by Rzeczpospolita, rmf24.pl and TVP Info. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Dmitry Peskov said on Monday, 16 November, that Europe must state its position on the peace process before joining talks, and that Russia does not want a temporary ceasefire.
Commission spokesperson Paula Pinho said multilateral talks with Russia in Europe are possible on 16 November, but no venue has been discussed.
Antonio Costa announced on 13 November in Dublin that France, Germany, Poland, the United Kingdom and Italy would join the negotiations, and Spain's José Manuel Albares objected to the team's makeup.
According to The New York Times, Russia sought the withdrawal of NATO troops from Poland and other eastern flank states during the 10-11 November Abu Dhabi round.
- 10 NovTrilateral Ukraine, US and Russia talks begin in Abu Dhabi, UAE, the first in that format in nine months
- 13 NovAntonio Costa announces at the Dublin EU summit that the E5 and EU institutions will join negotiations
- 16 NovPeskov makes European participation conditional, while the Commission says multilateral talks in Europe are possible
Kremlin sets terms for European role
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Monday, 16 November, that Russia makes the participation of European states in talks on ending the war in Ukraine dependent on their position toward the peace process. He accused the EU of lacking the will to support negotiations, arguing that European leaders were doing the opposite by declaring more support for Kyiv. Russian state media, cited by Reuters, carried his remarks. Peskov said Moscow had repeatedly indicated that European countries could join the talks, but wanted first to understand how their stance could help reach an agreement.
He said the talks so far had run in a three-way format involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States. Peskov pointed to statements by European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and other EU officials on continued support for Ukraine and rising pressure on Russia, which he said suggested Europe was unwilling to contribute to the peace process. He added that Russia did not want a temporary ceasefire, which he argued would give authorities in Kyiv time to recover, and that Moscow was seeking peace lasting for years and even centuries, with fighting continuing alongside negotiations. He declined to disclose details of Russia's talks with Washington, saying there was no point in publishing them.
Brussels keeps talks in Europe open
Paula Pinho, the European Commission spokesperson, said on Monday in Brussels that the EU accepts the possibility of multilateral peace talks on Ukraine in Europe with Russian participation. She added that no discussion has yet begun on where such negotiations would be held. Peskov, for his part, described the peace process as long and involving many complex issues.
E5 format and Spain's exclusion
On 13 November, at the EU summit in Dublin, European Council president Antonio Costa announced that France, Germany, Poland, the United Kingdom and Italy, the so-called E5, would take part in negotiations together with EU institutions, within a coalition of the willing. Spain was left out. Foreign minister José Manuel Albares criticised the team for having too many participants, which he said could cause communication chaos, and for missing several key institutional representatives. He said no decisions on European security, or on Europe and Ukraine, would be taken without Spain at the negotiating table. He also criticised the omission of EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas. El Mundo noted that Spain is the only large EU economy absent from the European negotiating team. Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez did not attend the Dublin summit, as he is campaigning ahead of snap parliamentary elections on 29 November.
Abu Dhabi talks and Russian demands
The last trilateral round between Ukraine, the United States and Russia took place on 10-11 November in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. It was the first meeting in that format in nine months. Russia's delegation was led by Vladimir Medinsky, an adviser to President Vladimir Putin, who said at the time that Moscow wanted a deal ending the war to include broader security arrangements in Europe.
According to The New York Times, Russia put forward demands during the negotiations for a postwar European security architecture resembling those it raised before its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. In an unofficial non-paper, Moscow reportedly sought the withdrawal of NATO troops from Poland and other eastern flank states of the alliance. Moscow says it still wants to understand how European positions could contribute to an agreement.
This article is part of a thread
The war in Ukraine and its limits
What changed since this entry:
- 16/11Kremlin says European states must state a position on the peace process before joining talks
- 16/11Kallas demands ceasefire and Russian concessions before substantive talks; Austria proposes ceasefire monitoring
- 16/11Commission due to present €45bn loan plan to member states on 18 November
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- RzeczpospolitaPeskov: EU does not want to negotiate, we will talk to it about Ukraine when it takes a positionPieskow: UE nie chce negocjować, będziemy z nią rozmawiać o Ukrainie, gdy zajmie stanowisko · original in Polish
- RzeczpospolitaThis large EU country does not like who will negotiate with Russia on behalf of Europe. It points to the absent oneTemu dużemu krajowi UE nie podoba się, kto w imieniu Europy będzie negocjował z Rosją. Wskazuje na nieobecną · original in Polish
- rmf24.plKremlin on talks about Ukraine: European participation requires clarificationKreml o rozmowach ws. Ukrainy: Udział Europy wymaga wyjaśnienia · original in Polish
- TVP InfoPeace talks about Ukraine. Kremlin sets conditions for European participationRozmowy pokojowe o Ukrainie. Kreml stawia warunki udziału Europy · original in Polish
- Dmitry Peskov
- Kremlin spokesman who set out Russia's conditions for European participation in the talks
- Paula Pinho
- European Commission spokesperson who said multilateral talks in Europe are possible
- Ursula von der Leyen
- President of the European Commission whose statements on Ukraine Peskov criticised
- Antonio Costa
- President of the European Council who announced the E5 negotiating format in Dublin
- José Manuel Albares
- Spanish foreign minister who criticised the negotiating team and Spain's exclusion
- Kaja Kallas
- EU foreign policy chief who is not included in the European negotiating team
- Pedro Sánchez
- Spanish prime minister campaigning for snap parliamentary elections on 29 November
- Vladimir Medinsky
- Putin adviser who led the Russian delegation at the Abu Dhabi talks
- Organizations
- European Union
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar