Diplomacy · Brussels and Dublin
EU leaders hand Ukraine talks to E5 group, sidelining foreign policy chief Kallas
EU member states agreed in Dublin on Friday, 13 November, that France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy and Poland will represent Europe in the next round of Ukraine talks. Kaja Kallas, the EU's foreign policy chief, was left out, and the Foreign Affairs Council in Brussels on 16 November exposed open questions over coordination with the other member states.
AI text based on reports by Η Ναυτεμπορική, Deutsche Welle, H Kαθημερινή and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Member states agreed in Dublin on 13 November that France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy and Poland, with EU institution representatives and NATO, will represent Europe, while the presence of the wider EU team at the next round is not yet confirmed.
Kaja Kallas did not contest the leaders' decision on 16 November, pointing to the EU treaties and saying she can keep working on the substance with the European External Action Service.
Konstantinos Kombos said he does not yet see coordination in place and called for a clear mandate, while Johann Wadephul said the Dublin agreement made the European position entirely clear.
Kallas called Moscow's demands maximalist, said Russia raised them already in 2021 to justify the war, and ruled out legal recognition of Ukrainian territory under Russian occupation.

Five capitals take the Ukraine negotiating lead
Member states agreed in Dublin on Friday, 13 November, on who will speak for Europe in the next round of Ukraine talks. The arrangement gives the role to the E5 group of France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy and Poland, alongside representatives of the EU institutions, with NATO also involved. The presence of the wider European team at that next round is not yet confirmed. A separate agreement among 42 European countries in Dublin set out common security principles, a point French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot raised in Brussels. Kaja Kallas, the EU's foreign policy chief, is not part of the negotiating format.
Kallas calls Moscow's demands maximalist
After the Foreign Affairs Council in Brussels on 16 November, Kallas described Moscow's demands as maximalist and said a ceasefire must come first, followed by a peace agreement. In her account, Russia seeks to carve up Ukraine, limit NATO's presence and win a veto over decisions on European security. She said Moscow had invoked these demands as a justification for the war back in 2021 and now uses them to justify its continuation. Any settlement, she argued, must safeguard Ukraine's sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity, along with its freedom to choose the countries and organisations it allies with. She ruled out legal recognition of Ukrainian territory under Russian occupation and called for Russia to be held accountable for war crimes.
Kallas says the leaders' choice stands and she keeps working
Asked why she was left out of the European delegation, Kallas pointed to the EU treaties, which assign responsibility for foreign and security policy. She said the leaders had decided, so the decision belonged to them. She noted that she works with foreign ministers every month and draws on the expertise of the European External Action Service, and added that she can keep working on the substance. She also acknowledged that European leaders may take different decisions, and voiced the expectation that no parallel structures would be built that add costs to the EU budget.
Ministers split on coordination with the 27
Cypriot Foreign Minister Konstantinos Kombos raised the question of how member states will be kept informed and coordinated, saying he does not yet see that coordination in place. He argued that the negotiating team needs a clear mandate, strategic objectives and a mechanism to brief the Council. German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul struck a more confident note, saying the content of the European position is entirely clear now that Dublin settled who will negotiate. He described the sovereignty of states and their right to choose alliances as non-negotiable, and said Ukraine's path toward NATO is irreversible.
Paris warns Moscow, and the axis question returns
Barrot warned Moscow against underestimating Europeans and argued that no outside party can determine the future of European security. A NewsIT commentary published on 16 November argues that the Franco-German axis, long the centre of EU decision-making, has lost its central role, with the E5 format emerging in its place. The same commentary says it is unclear what the E5 amounts to in practice and that Kallas was sidelined on the Ukraine file.
What comes next
The next round of talks has no confirmed European team yet, and the Foreign Affairs Council left open how the 27 will coordinate with the negotiators. A new EU sanctions package is reported to be imminent, though the available reporting gives no further details on its contents or timing.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Η ΝαυτεμπορικήKallas: Moscow's demands for Ukraine are “maximalist”Κάλας: "Μαξιμαλιστικές" οι αξιώσεις της Μόσχας για την Ουκρανία - Νέο πακέτο κυρώσεων προ των πυλών · original in Greek
- Deutsche WelleUkraine: The EU bypasses Kaja KallasΟυκρανία: Η ΕΕ παρακάμπτει την Κάγια Κάλας · original in Greek
- H KαθημερινήUkraine: The bypassing of Kallas and the “cracks” in European unityΟυκρανία: Η παράκαμψη της Κάλας και οι "ρωγμές" στην ευρωπαϊκή ενότητα · original in Greek
- NewsITThe EU's “new architecture” of power no longer depends on the Franco-German axisΗ "νέα αρχιτεκτονική" ισχύος της ΕΕ δεν εξαρτάται πλέον από τον γαλλογερμανικό άξονα · original in Greek
- Kaja Kallas
- EU High Representative for foreign affairs and security policy, left out of the Ukraine negotiating format
- Johann Wadephul
- German Foreign Minister who said the Dublin agreement settled who will negotiate
- Jean-Noël Barrot
- French Foreign Minister who warned Moscow against underestimating Europeans
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar