Diplomacy · Brussels
Kallas calls Russian Ukraine demands absurd and says EU must seek concessions in return
EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said on Monday, 16 November, that Moscow's demands in the Ukraine talks are not serious. She spoke as she arrived at the Foreign Affairs Council in Brussels and urged the bloc to ask what it would receive in return.
AI text based on reports by Il Fatto Quotidiano, ΣΚΑΪ, Il Sole 24 ORE and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On Monday, 16 November, Kaja Kallas told reporters arriving at the Foreign Affairs Council in Brussels that Russia's demands in the Ukraine talks are maximalist and not serious.
Kallas said Russia presented a list of demands in 2021 that served as a pretext for war, and that Moscow now repeats those demands with more added.
Kallas said a ceasefire is the indispensable condition before negotiations can start, and that Russia is meanwhile escalating attacks on railways, bridges and energy facilities.
A document published by the New York Times reportedly says Moscow asked for NATO to withdraw to its 1997 borders, the demand Kallas was responding to.

Kallas calls Russian demands absurd
On Monday, 16 November, Kaja Kallas, the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs, said she did not believe Russia's demands in the Ukraine negotiations were serious. Speaking as she arrived at the Foreign Affairs Council in Brussels, she called the demands maximalist and absurd. The former Estonian prime minister argued that, looking at history, none of the Eastern European countries concerned had ever attacked Russia. She described a familiar pattern in which Moscow puts forward a long list of claims, adds more of them, and then appears reasonable when it steps back from some of them.
A document on NATO and a repeated list
Her remarks responded to a document published by the New York Times, according to which Moscow reportedly asked for NATO to withdraw to its 1997 borders. Kallas said Russia had presented a list of demands in 2021 that worked as a clear pretext for war, and that the same demands now return with more added to them. She said the list should be viewed with complete clarity rather than as a serious basis for talks. According to her, Russia claims it is waiting for European proposals and says the Europeans have offered nothing, which she described as exactly the tactic Moscow always uses. She argued that it was suddenly becoming the Europeans' responsibility to offer something, even though those who started the war had not made any offer.
A ceasefire before any talks
Kallas said a ceasefire is the indispensable condition for any negotiation to begin, and that no sign of one is visible at present. She pointed to existing security agreements that Russia had accepted, including the Helsinki Final Act and the Budapest Memorandum, and said the problem is that Russia is not honouring them. She said clear Russian commitments to respect those agreements were needed. Meanwhile, she said, Russia is escalating its attacks on railway lines, bridges and energy facilities. In her account, the aim is to inflict as much suffering as possible on the civilian population before the difficult winter.
What the EU should ask for
Kallas urged negotiators to ask what the other side wanted in return for its concessions, and whether counter-demands had been put forward when maximalist demands were made. She said the EU should also consider what it can offer, pointing to sanctions and frozen Russian assets as the levers it already holds. She expressed the hope that no step would be taken without gaining something in return, both on Ukraine and on European security. She described European security as a long-term question that cannot be settled by a single round of talks. Her remarks were made in the margins of the Foreign Affairs Council meeting in Brussels on the same day.
This article is part of a thread
Russia and Ukraine: the push for talks
What changed since this entry:
- 16/11Kallas calls Russian demands absurd and urges the EU to seek concessions
- 16/11Von der Leyen says Europe will engage closely through the EU plus five-country format
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Il Fatto QuotidianoUkraine, Kallas: “Russia's demands are absurd. First Moscow accepts a truce, then we negotiate”Ucraina, Kallas: "Le richieste della Russia sono assurde. Prima Mosca accetti una tregua, poi trattiamo" · original in Italian
- ΣΚΑΪKallas: The demands Russia had in 2021 have increased, and they are absurdΚάλας: Οι απαιτήσεις που είχε η Ρωσία το 2021 αυξήθηκαν, και είναι παράλογες · original in Greek
- Il Sole 24 OREUkraine: Kallas, absurd demands from Moscow, pretext not to end warUcraina: Kallas, da Mosca richieste assurde, pretesto per non finire guerra · original in Italian
- AdnkronosKallas: Russian demands on Ukraine are absurd and unacceptableKallas: le richieste russe sull'Ucraina sono assurde e Iinaccettabili · original in Italian
- Kaja Kallas
- EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Vice-President of the European Commission, who criticised Russia's demands at the Foreign Affairs Council
- Organizations
- European Union
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar