Government · Rome
Schlein backs super-rich tax as centre-left wealth-tax plans diverge
Elly Schlein said on 15 November that she favours a tax on the super-rich at national level, but the centre-left has not agreed on one wealth-tax design. The proposals from AVS, M5S and the PD differ sharply in thresholds, bases and revenue estimates.
AI text based on reports by Open, Fanpage, Il Messaggero and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
At the L'Italia di Domani event, PD leader Elly Schlein said she has always favoured a tax on the super-rich, which could be introduced nationally and not only at European level.
AVS proposes a levy on net wealth above 5.4 million euros, including property, estimated by the party at nearly 16 billion euros a year. The M5S targets financial gains, and the PD backs Gabriel Zucman's 2% minimum tax on fortunes above 100 million euros.
According to Open, the budget applies a 26% levy on gains of at least 800,000 euros from shares and corporate stakes when people move their tax residence abroad, a measure Schlein cited as an argument for wealth taxation.
Schlein said whoever wins the centre-left primaries would lead an alliance bound by a programme, citing 21 shared economic policy points and a minimum wage of 10 euros an hour.
Schlein's case for a tax on the super-rich
On 15 November Elly Schlein, leader of the Partito Democratico (PD), spoke at the "L'Italia di Domani" event and said she had always been in favour of a tax on the super-rich. She argued that such a levy could be introduced at national level, not only at European level, and said she personally supported it because she read the Italian Constitution as clear on the point. Schlein called for a full overhaul of a tax system that she said the right had made increasingly unfair, adding that taxes should be paid where profits are made. Addressing the government, she accused Giorgia Meloni's administration of raising taxes on the middle class and said her side was talking about multi-millionaires.
“To Meloni we say that we will not raise taxes on the middle class, she is the one who did it.”
She added that the centre-left was the only group fighting so that no workers would be treated as second-class citizens, in the terms she used at the event.
The exit tax in the budget
According to Open, the budget introduces a new 26% levy on gains of at least 800,000 euros from shares and stakes in companies, applied to people who move their tax residence from Italy abroad. Schlein used the measure to argue that the right had itself supplied an argument for taxing large fortunes. She tied that point to the broader need for a tax system that falls more fairly on those who make the most money. The exit tax thus became the reference point in her case, since she presented it as a rule the government had already accepted for large holdings. Her remarks were made in the same week the centre-left was debating amendments to the budget.
Three centre-left proposals
Open reports that the centre-left has no agreement yet on a wealth tax, with three distinct models on the table. AVS wants a progressive wealth tax on net wealth above 5.4 million euros, including property, which would affect about 50,000 taxpayers, the richest 0.1% of the population. The party estimates it would raise nearly 16 billion euros a year. The M5S prefers a levy on financial income only, and a bill signed by senator Mario Turco in the Senate would raise the tax on large financial gains, now taxed at 0.2% a year, progressively up to 1% for gains above 5 million euros. That bill also adds a levy on high-frequency trading. The PD backs the proposal of French economist Gabriel Zucman, a minimum annual tax of 2% on fortunes above 100 million euros. Giuseppe Conte explained the M5S position this way:
“When I say no to a wealth tax, I do not mean no to taxation or a levy on the super-rich.”
A Fanpage commentary, by contrast, says the PD, AVS and M5S have reportedly found common ground, with the M5S still hesitant. Open's reporting says no agreement exists for now.
- AVS net wealth threshold
- 5.4 million euros
- PD Zucman proposal threshold
- 100 million euros
Data from the article text
Revenue estimates and the primaries
The Fanpage commentary argues for a 1% tax on wealth above 2 million euros, excluding first homes. It cites estimates from CGIL and the Comitato 1% Equo that such a levy would raise at least about 20 billion euros a year, while CGIL puts the figure at 26 billion. The commentary also notes that the budget sets aside 12 billion euros, with another 14 billion tied to energy and military investment and financed by borrowing. On the coalition's internal politics, Schlein said the winner of the centre-left primaries would lead an alliance rather than a single party.
“Whoever wins the primaries will not be the head of their party but the head of an alliance bound by the programme.”
Schlein also said the coalition had 21 shared points of economic policy and that nobody should earn less than 10 euros an hour if they work, a position she described as shared across the coalition.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- OpenThe wealth tax of the Campo Largo: three ideas to tax the richLa patrimoniale del Campo Largo: tre idee per tassare i ricchi · original in Italian
- FanpageThe two real reasons why taxing the super-rich is right and necessaryI due veri motivi per cui tassare i super ricchi è giusto e necessario · original in Italian
- Il MessaggeroSchlein: “Whoever wins the primaries will be the head of an alliance bound by the programme. I am in favour of a tax on the super-rich”Schlein: "Chi vince le primarie sarà capo di un'alleanza vincolata dal programma. Io favorevole a una tassa sui super ricchi" · original in Italian
- Tgcom24Pd, Schlein: “Whoever wins the primaries will be the head of an alliance bound by the programme”Pd, Schlein: "Chi vince le primarie sarà capo di un'alleanza vincolata dal programma" · original in Italian
- Elly Schlein
- Leader of the Partito Democratico (PD) who spoke at the L'Italia di Domani event about a tax on the super-rich
- Giorgia Meloni
- Italian prime minister whose government's budget includes the exit tax that Schlein cited
- Giuseppe Conte
- Quoted by Open on the M5S position against a wealth tax and in favour of a levy on the super-rich
- Gabriel Zucman
- French economist whose proposal of a 2% minimum annual tax on fortunes above 100 million euros the PD backs
- Mario Turco
- Senator who signed the M5S bill on taxing large financial gains
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar