Government · Rome

Centre-left split on wealth tax: Conte says no, Avs insists it goes in the programme

At the Greens' 40th anniversary festival in Rome on 15 November, Giuseppe Conte ruled out a 'patrimoniale' while leaving room for a levy on the super-rich, and Avs demanded the tax be written into the coalition programme.

AI text based on reports by Il Messaggero, il Giornale.it, Fanpage and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Canale ufficiale, CC BY-SA 2.0 (Wikimedia Commons, cropped). File photo, 2024

A split over the wealth tax

On 15 November, at the festival marking the 40th anniversary of the Greens in Rome, the centre-left's dispute over a 'patrimoniale' (wealth tax) came into the open. Giuseppe Conte, leader of the Five Star Movement (M5S), said he opposed a wealth tax but not a levy on the super-rich. He proposed taxing large financial fortunes instead, arguing that this was the best way to secure growth and equity. Conte also said the alliance had two proposals and that they should be compared with Avs's.

“When I say no to a wealth tax, I do not mean no to taxation, or to a levy on the super-rich.”

Giuseppe Conte, leader of the Five Star Movement

Conte added that the coalition must generate resources to restore purchasing power, because real wages have fallen sharply for the poorest households, or else it would not be progressive.

Avs demands the tax in the programme

Nicola Fratoianni, leader of Alleanza Verdi Sinistra (Avs), said a tax on very large fortunes, which he also called a solidarity contribution, is a necessity and that Avs would work to have it in the programme. He told allies that without Avs there is no alternative, and said the thematic tables now under way were a result the Greens had secured. He listed priorities including the 'just transition', research, health and schools, and argued that these require resources. He also said those resources should come from reversing the tax policy of recent decades.

“Without Avs, there is no alternative.”

Nicola Fratoianni, leader of Alleanza Verdi Sinistra

Angelo Bonelli, co-spokesperson of Europa Verde and an Avs deputy, set the threshold for the proposed levy at assets above 5.4 million euros. He called it a solidarity contribution and said that if the name 'patrimoniale' bothered anyone, it could be changed, since the substance would stay the same.

“If someone is bothered by the name 'patrimoniale', let's change it, the substance does not change.”

Angelo Bonelli, co-spokesperson of Europa Verde and Avs deputy

Income support and the joint programme

Bonelli said the centre-left's thematic tables were going very well and that Avs had no preclusion on the reddito di cittadinanza, but that an income guarantee requires finding resources, which he wanted to take from the wealth tax. He said not addressing the issue would be wrong, and warned against repeating what he described as the right's approach of cutting health, schools, transport and climate policy, with costs falling on pensioners and the middle class. Reports on the labour table list a 10 euro hourly minimum wage, shorter working hours with equal pay, equal parental leave, and income and pensions among the planned items. An anti-poverty tool along the lines of the reddito di cittadinanza is reportedly expected in the joint programme, possibly under a new name, but its design has not yet been agreed. The labour table meets again on Monday 16 November.

Reactions and open questions

Elly Schlein, secretary of the Democratic Party (PD), told the Greens' event that the coalition would win the elections together and bring a progressive, feminist and ecological government to the country. Later the same day, at the L'Italia di Domani event, she said she had always favoured a tax on the super-rich, which could be applied at national level. Italia Viva is reluctant about the reddito di cittadinanza label, while M5S negotiators want to keep it. Avs has reportedly worried that the planned primaries could penalise it by focusing attention only on the PD and the M5S. The question of arms for Kyiv also remains unresolved in the talks.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Rome
Rome · Italy

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar