AI & Tech · New York City, Los Angeles, and Chicago
Google staff urge it to let schools keep Search without AI features
Hundreds of Google employees and contractors have signed a union petition asking the company to let schools use Search without its AI features, after Google tied Search access for K-12 students to AI.
AI text based on reports by engadget, The Next Web and Bloomberg Business. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
AI is off by default for K-12 students, and a school that turns Search back on also receives Google's AI features, according to reporting on Google's November policy.
Bloomberg reported more than 540 Google employees and contractors signed the union petition on Thursday, 19 November, while Engadget reported more than 500.
School districts in New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are considering an alternate search engine, according to The New York Times.
Google's Chrome operating system ran on 58% of laptops and tablets shipped to US schools last year, per Futuresource Consulting, and will stop getting updates in 2034.
Google's policy and the petition
In November, Google set a policy under which AI is off by default for K-12 students, and Gemini and Search stay disabled on student accounts until a school enables them. Because AI is built into Search, a school that turns Search back on also receives its AI features, while a school that wants no AI at all has to do without Google Search. On Thursday, 19 November, Bloomberg reported that more than 540 Google employees and contractors had signed a union petition asking the company to let schools use Search without AI. Engadget reported more than 500 signatures in its own coverage, so the figures differ by outlet.
The Alphabet Workers Union, which is CWA Local 9009, issued a statement on 19 November criticising how Google has handled the issue. The statement said:
“Any opportunity to drive positive change with AI in education will rely on educators having the freedom to choose how to implement it in their curriculum.”
What the petition asks for
The letter is addressed to CEO Sundar Pichai, to Elizabeth Reid, who heads Search, and to Chris Phillips, the education chief. It asks Google to let schools switch off AI features in Search while keeping the search tool usable. The union warned that cutting schools off from Search could push them away from Google products altogether. Google had not immediately commented to Bloomberg when the report was published.
Schools weigh alternatives
According to The New York Times, school districts in New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are weighing a move to a different search provider rather than hand Google control over how students use AI. Leaving is hard, though. Dan Carroll, co-founder of the edtech startup Clever, said Chromebooks are built around Google's software and that changing search engines takes time and training. Carroll summed up the position in one line:
“It's a real strategic pickle.”
The stakes for Google's own software are also high. Its Chrome operating system, which stops receiving updates in 2034, ran on 58% of laptops and tablets shipped to US schools last year, according to Futuresource Consulting.
Scrutiny and litigation
Senator Ed Markey sent Google a letter on 9 November asking whether schools could keep Search while AI remained switched off. In July 2026, Common Sense Media called Google's AI Search an "unacceptable risk" for students. In November, a family sued Google after their girl's exchanges with its AI tools on a school-issued device, and Google said it is reviewing the claims. The case sits within a wider rise in lawsuits against AI companies over alleged harm to users, children among them.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Sundar Pichai
- Google CEO, addressee of the employee petition
- Elizabeth Reid
- Head of Google Search, addressee of the petition
- Chris Phillips
- Google education chief, addressee of the petition
- Ed Markey
- US senator who wrote to Google on 9 November about keeping Search with AI switched off
- Dan Carroll
- Co-founder of edtech startup Clever, commenting on the difficulty of leaving Google
- Places
- New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago
- Organizations
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar