Safety · Brussels

EU auditors say PFAS rules fail to protect health, food limits too weak

Weekly servings of beef, salmon, eggs or anchovies can exceed the permitted PFAS level, and the European Court of Auditors says EU rules are too slow to keep up with these persistent chemicals.

AI text based on reports by La Libre.be, de Volkskrant, LaVanguardia and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Brussels · Belgium
How it came to this
  1. 2019Stientje van Veldhoven, then state secretary, calls for an EU-wide PFAS ban
  2. 2023Netherlands and four other countries formally propose a ban
  3. 18 NovEuropean Court of Auditors publishes its PFAS report

Auditors find EU protection falls short

The European Court of Auditors concluded in a report published on Wednesday, 18 November, that the EU is not protecting its citizens from PFAS, a group of persistent chemicals often called forever chemicals. The substances are prized for resisting water, grease, stains and extreme heat, which is why they turn up in thousands of products, from waterproof clothing and packaging to cosmetics and furniture. Studies link exposure to cancer, reproductive problems and hormone disruption, and the auditors cite estimates putting related health spending in Europe at 52 to 84 billion euros a year. The court member responsible for the audit, Joëlle Elvinger, framed the challenge this way.

“Although these chemical substances are eternal, there are ways to limit their harmful effects on the population and the environment.”

Joëlle Elvinger, member of the European Court of Auditors responsible for the PFAS audit

Rules take years and manufacturers swap substances

Under the current framework, adopting a restriction on a specific PFAS takes about five years on average, a window in which manufacturers can replace the banned substance with a similar chemical that may be just as harmful. Most PFAS are not registered under REACH, the EU's chemicals regulation, so producers have no duty to test them and regulators hold little data on many of them. PTFE, better known as Teflon, is one widely used example, found in non-stick pans and waterproof clothing. In 2019 Stientje van Veldhoven, then state secretary for the environment and now a Dutch minister, called for an EU-wide PFAS ban. In 2023 the Netherlands and four other countries formally proposed such a ban, but the proposal now sits with European scientists who need about four years to advise. Elvinger said the uncertainty is damaging because it blocks other initiatives in the meantime.

Food and water limits fall short

The auditors say the current maximum levels for food and water do not sufficiently protect human health, even though these are the main routes through which people are exposed. Drinking water limits have generally been respected in recent years, but they rest on scientific data from 2017, and PFAS have kept accumulating in soil and water since then. The auditors warn that the limits could be exceeded far more often in future, raising health risks for consumers and the cost of treating water. EU food standards, which Belgium also follows, aim to keep contamination as low as reasonably achievable but do not guarantee that regular consumption is risk-free over the long term. The court calculated that the permitted level can be exceeded once a person eats more than 7 g of anchovies, 39 g of wild salmon, 181 g of eggs or 237 g of beef in a week, quantities the auditors describe as fairly moderate. Yet fewer than 2% of sampled food exceeds the limits, and the total a person takes in weekly from several sources can still be too high.

Weekly amount of one food that can exceed the PFAS maximumg per week
Anchovies
7 g per week
Wild salmon
39 g per week
Eggs
181 g per week
Beef
237 g per week

Data from the article text

Weak monitoring and a call for speed

The auditors say monitoring is another weak point, since the system relies largely on companies regulating themselves. One in three of the 27 member states carried out no PFAS-specific inspection to check compliance with chemicals legislation in the 2020 to 2025 period. José Parente, the audit's principal manager, told La Vanguardia that the EU procedures for regulating PFAS are complex and long, which makes them unsuited to the problem. The auditors add that rules cannot keep pace with the rising production and use of these substances, leaving people and the environment highly exposed. The report ends with a call for quicker action from Brussels.

“Without faster and firmer action by the EU, these extremely persistent substances will continue to resist the very rules meant to govern them.”

European Court of Auditors

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Brussels
Organizations
European Union

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar