Safety

GNR detains 16 over irregular ETAR sludge spreading; environmental group warns of wider problem

The GNR says 16 suspects were detained in the Cloaca Máxima operation over alleged irregular spreading of treatment plant sludge on farm and forest land. The environmental group ZERO says the case may be only the tip of the iceberg.

AI text based on reports by SAPO and RTP. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

How it came to this
  1. 2018ZERO alerts the APA and Águas de Portugal to 131,231 tonnes of sludge with no known destination
  2. 12 NovGNR announces the detention of 16 suspects in the Cloaca Máxima operation
  3. 17 NovZERO calls for urgent intervention by the authorities

The GNR operation

The Guarda Nacional Republicana (GNR) announced on 12 November the detention of 16 suspects in the Cloaca Máxima operation. Police say the suspects were involved in an alleged scheme to send sludge from wastewater treatment plants (ETAR) and other industrial activities to farm and forest land. According to Lusa, the investigation was launched roughly two years earlier, covered nine districts and involved 36 searches.

Alleged fraud and charges

According to the GNR, the waste was documented as organic compost even though it did not meet the legal conditions for application to soils. Investigators also found signs of forged electronic records and of manipulated samples used to approve sludge management plans. The GNR said the evidence pointed to pollution, document forgery, computer forgery, money laundering and criminal association, linked to coordinated conduct among waste operators, carriers and others involved in unloading. According to RTP, the suspects received state money for several years for the collection, transport, treatment and recovery of sludge that was labelled as compost.

ZERO's 2018 warning

The environmental association ZERO says that in 2018 it studied waste tracking guides (eGAR) supplied by the Portuguese Environment Agency (APA) for the first half of that year. It counted 261,965 tonnes of sludge produced, of which 131,231 tonnes were stored with no known final destination. ZERO says it passed these results to the APA and to Águas de Portugal, the main operator of domestic ETARs, but the warning had no consequences.

ZERO study: sludge from ETARs, first half of 2018tonnes
Sludge produced
261965 tonnes
Stored with no known final destination
131231 tonnes

Data from the article text

Why ZERO says the problem is wider

ZERO argues the detained cases may be only the tip of the iceberg. It points to the prices paid by domestic ETAR operators to sludge management companies, which it says may be too low to ensure proper disposal. The statement put the untraced amount at about 130,000 tonnes and said half of the sludge produced in that period had no known destination and was probably being dumped illegally on soils. The association also questions the APA, which holds the eGAR route data and, according to ZERO, did not use it for more than a decade to alert inspectors or contact the operators involved.

“An urgent intervention by the competent authorities is needed to force those involved to comply with the law, protecting human health and the environment”

ZERO

Key dates

The sequence runs from the 2018 warning to the November detentions and ZERO's latest statement on 17 November. The 2018 analysis covered only the first half of that year, while the GNR announced the detentions on 12 November.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Portugal

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar