Government · Berlin
Berlin Left moves to expel Vanessa Emde, vote set for 24 November
The Left faction board in Berlin's state parliament has formally submitted a motion to exclude Vanessa Emde from the group. Members are expected to vote on Tuesday, 24 November, and a two-thirds majority is required.
AI text based on reports by N-tv, DIE WELT, Spiegel Online and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The Left faction board adopted a motion to exclude Vanessa Emde on Tuesday, 17 November, and brought it before the 44-member group.
The faction vote is expected on Tuesday, 24 November, and needs a two-thirds majority; Tagesspiegel puts the threshold at 30 of 44 members.
The Greens and SPD made Emde's exclusion a condition for a coalition with the Left, and Tagesspiegel says a failed motion would likely end the coalition talks.
Emde rejected repeated requests from the state party leadership to resign her mandate, and in a letter she said she would keep exercising it.
Emde won a direct mandate in Neukölln with 46.2% of first votes in the 20 September election and was criticised for her Middle East remarks, including a mid-October revocation of an anti-antisemitism declaration.
- 31 OctEmde protests against the party leadership outside a Linke party congress
- 17 NovFaction board adopts the exclusion motion and brings it before the group
- 24 NovFaction vote on Emde's exclusion expected
A motion filed after a week of conflict
On Tuesday, 17 November, the board of the Left faction in the Berlin House of Representatives adopted a motion to exclude Vanessa Emde and brought it before the full group of 44 members. The step followed an announcement made a week earlier that the board would take it. The faction said Emde had shown no willingness to return to the working basis the members had agreed together. Tagesspiegel reported that the motion was delivered to her before the afternoon faction meeting began. Emde attended the session, left without a word and did not answer questions from journalists.
Why the board says it acted
The motion says the faction and the state party leaders tried several times to reach Emde, without success. She had neither answered the state leadership's call to give up her seat nor met the conditions they had set. The board therefore concluded that loss of trust and damage to the faction left no other option than an exclusion request. The faction's statement also pointed to its statutes, which refer to the mandate-holders' agreement and party resolutions.
“We very much regret that this step has become necessary.”
Emde's record and her refusal to step down
Emde entered the state parliament after the Berlin election on 20 September, winning a direct mandate in Neukölln with 46.2% of the first votes. She has been criticised for her comments on the Middle East conflict, and reports say she is accused of questioning Israel's right to exist. In mid-October she revoked a faction declaration against antisemitism that she had signed just two days earlier, a step that burdened coalition talks between Linke, Greens and SPD. Faction chair Tobias Schulze said at the time that there was no longer a common working basis with her. On 31 October she protested against the party leadership outside a Linke party congress.
Emde has refused to give up her seat and, in a letter to the party leadership reported by dpa, said she would keep exercising it. She wrote:
“That I am prepared to work constructively in the parliamentary group, I have made clear more than once.”
Vote on 24 November and coalition stakes
The vote is expected on Tuesday, 24 November, and Emde is set to have the chance to respond personally to the allegations before it takes place. Exclusion requires a two-thirds majority of the group's 44 members, which Tagesspiegel puts at 30 votes. The Greens and the SPD, the two potential coalition partners of the Left, have made her exclusion a condition for a coalition, though with differing firmness. Tagesspiegel describes the outcome as a significant turning point on the way to an alliance of Linke, Greens and SPD. If the motion fails, the faction leadership would be seriously damaged and the coalition talks would presumably have failed.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- N-tvThe Day: Berlin Left sets in motion the faction exclusion of Vanessa EmdeDer Tag: Berliner Linke bringt Fraktionsausschluss von Vanessa Emde auf Weg · original in German
- DIE WELTDecision on 24 November: “We no longer trust her” - Berlin Left requests exclusion of Vanessa EmdeEntscheidung am 24. November: "Wir vertrauen ihr nicht mehr" - Berliner Linke beantragt Ausschluss von Vanessa Emde · original in German
- Spiegel OnlineBerlin Left files motion for faction exclusion of Vanessa EmdeBerliner Linke bringt Antrag auf Fraktionsausschluss von Vanessa Emde ein · original in German
- Der TagesspiegelVanessa Emde to leave faction: Berlin Left leadership adopts exclusion motionVanessa Emde soll Fraktion verlassen: Berliner Linken-Spitze beschließt Ausschlussantrag · original in German
- Tobias Schulze
- Chair of the Left faction in the Berlin House of Representatives
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar