Government · Berlin and Neukölln
Berlin Left MP Vanessa Emde doubts party's affordability pledge as expulsion vote nears
Emde, a Left Party MP in the Berlin House of Representatives, questions the party's central promise as the faction leadership prepares a motion to expel her.
AI text based on reports by DIE WELT, Der Tagesspiegel and stern.de. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On Saturday, 14 November, Emde told a Kreuzberg congress that 'Berlin bezahlbar machen' is doubtful in a government with the SPD and the Greens, because Berlin lacks the financial means and only the federal government can redistribute.
The faction leadership will bring an exclusion motion before the faction on Tuesday, 17 November. Emde can be excluded only if at least 30 of the 44 MPs vote for it one week later.
Former Thuringian minister-president Bodo Ramelow told ZDF that Emde should leave the faction voluntarily, citing broken trust after she signed the joint exploratory paper and publicly said the opposite the next day, without asking her to give up her direct mandate.
A CDU draft law would have parliament president Hendrikje Klein request criminal record data for staff of MPs and factions, and deny funding to staff judged unreliable, including after a conviction for state security offences in the last five years.
- 14 NovEmde questions the pledge at the Zündfunke congress in Kreuzberg
- 15 NovRamelow's call for Emde to leave the faction is reported
- 17 NovFaction leadership's exclusion motion is scheduled before the faction
- One week after 17 NovemberExclusion requires at least 30 of 44 MPs to vote in favour
Doubts over the campaign pledge
Vanessa Emde, a Left Party member of the Berlin House of Representatives, said on Saturday, 14 November, that she doubts the party's central campaign promise can be kept in a government with the SPD and the Greens. Speaking at the 'Zündfunke' congress of the Trotskyist group 'Sozialismus von unten' in a former substation in Kreuzberg, she argued that social problems are too large and that the state of Berlin lacks the financial means to tackle them. In her view, only the federal government could raise the money needed for redistribution. Her core argument was short.
“Left politics needs redistribution”
In Neukölln, where she won 46.2% of the votes as a direct candidate, she said the party never set out to make Berlin affordable. The aim there, she said, was to build 'strongholds of solidarity resistance'. She also said a left government would need pressure from the street to light a fire under it, and she framed the political fight as one of class rather than campaigns.
“The history is not a history of election campaigns, the history is a history of class struggles.”
A complaint about a right turn in the party
Tagesspiegel reports that at a meeting of the Sonnenallee grassroots group in Neukölln, Emde said the party had been gripped by a 'right turn'. She blamed pressure from the Greens and the SPD, a 'smear campaign by the press' and the prospect of leading the government for the party distancing itself from her. In her account, the party was sacrificing its principles and its personnel to do so. She expects a red-red-green coalition to be formed anyway, and in that case her wing would have to act as opposition inside the government, backing street protests against cuts.
Emde has spent weeks negotiating with the state and faction leadership over whether she can remain in the faction. She has been criticised for her remarks on the Middle East conflict, and critics accuse her of indirectly denying Israel's right to exist during the election campaign.
Ramelow calls for her to leave the faction
Bodo Ramelow, the former Thuringian minister-president, told ZDF that Emde is not obliged to stay in the faction if she does not want to back the basis agreed for a possible government in Berlin. He did not ask her to give up her direct mandate, which would let her keep working in the House as a directly elected member. His objection concerns trust rather than her positions on the Middle East. In his words:
“My accusation against Ms Emde is that she signed the joint exploratory paper and the next day publicly declared the opposite. That, I think, destroys all trust.”
Ramelow said the Berlin state association and a state party conference had both backed the joint basis for government. He warned against outside interference, saying the coalition talks of the three parties were running well and in an orderly way, while the public debate is led by people outside Berlin who have no remit. He acknowledged that some party members reject joining a government in principle, a view he said he could understand but did not share.
Exclusion procedure and a CDU vetting plan
The faction leadership has decided to file a motion to exclude Emde, to be brought before the faction on Tuesday, 17 November. Exclusion goes through only if at least 30 of the faction's 44 MPs vote for it one week later. Tagesspiegel's live blog of 15 November had put the earliest possible vote two weeks away.
- Faction MPs
- 44 MPs
- Votes needed to exclude (minimum)
- 30 MPs
Data from the article text
Separately, the Berlin CDU has drafted a law for an extremism check on all staff of MPs and factions in the state parliament. According to the draft, which the German Press Agency has obtained, parliament president Hendrikje Klein (Left) would request criminal record data from the Federal Central Register with the employee's consent, and would query the Berlin state criminal police and state domestic intelligence. Staff judged unreliable would lose public funding, and a conviction for offences against the state in the last five years would count against reliability.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- DIE WELTVanessa Emde: Left MP doubts election pledge “Make Berlin affordable”Vanessa Emde: Linken-Abgeordnete zweifelt an Wahlversprechen "Berlin bezahlbar machen" · original in German
- Der TagesspiegelThe symbol politician: Vanessa Emde, the Palestine question and the deep rift in the Berlin LeftDie Symbolpolitikerin: Vanessa Emde, die Palästinafrage und der tiefe Riss in der Berliner Linken · original in German
- Der Tagesspiegel“Every trust destroyed”: Ramelow demands Vanessa Emde's exit from the Berlin Left faction"Jedes Vertrauen zerstört": Ramelow fordert Austritt von Vanessa Emde aus Berliner Linksfraktion · original in German
- stern.deRamelow accuses Emde of breach of trustRamelow wirft Emde Vertrauensbruch vor · original in German
- Bodo Ramelow
- Left politician and former Thuringian minister-president who called on Emde to leave the faction
- Hendrikje Klein
- Left politician and president of the Berlin House of Representatives, named in the CDU draft vetting law
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar