Health & Education · Vicenza and Perugia

Vicenza court gives parents two years each over son's delayed cancer treatment

A Vicenza court convicted the parents of culpable homicide after their 14-year-old son died in January 2024 of osteosarcoma, following months of treatment delays under the Hamer Method. Prosecutors had asked for 14 years for each parent.

AI text based on reports by La Repubblica.it and ANSA.it. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Vicenza, Perugia · Italy

Verdict in Vicenza

The Vicenza court found the couple guilty of culpable homicide on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, and sentenced each parent to two years in prison. Their son, a 14-year-old, died in January 2024 of osteosarcoma after his treatment had been delayed for months. The judges reclassified the charge as culpable homicide, the classification the defence had requested at the preliminary hearing, and applied the sentence reduction that comes with the abbreviated trial procedure. Prosecutors had asked for 14 years for each parent, so the sentence handed down is far shorter than their request.

Months of delay

When the boy was diagnosed, his parents postponed the biopsy and the start of chemotherapy, relying instead on the Hamer Method. That choice followed the advice of a doctor who was still registered with the medical association at the time and has since been suspended. The parents went ahead despite the opposing view of several specialists. For months the boy stayed in a community in Tuscany, where he was treated with clay poultices, natural anti-inflammatories and massage. He was taken to the hospital in Perugia only when his condition had become desperate, and the tumour had by then spread rapidly. Chemotherapy started too late could not save him.

What the method claims

The Hamer Method was developed in the 1980s by former German physician Ryke Geerd Hamer (1935-2017). It holds that cancer and other illnesses stem from biological conflicts triggered by an emotional shock, and that they can be healed without conventional medicine. Italy's Istituto superiore di sanità, the medical association and scientific societies have all rejected the method. Specialists heard in court said that traditional therapies could have saved the boy.

Prosecution and defence

In court, the prosecutor acknowledged that the tumour was the primary cause of death. He said the parents did not want their son to die, but that they had continued the alternative treatments negligently and recklessly while aware of the danger. He added:

“Nevertheless, there is criminal liability linked to having failed to take an action that could have prevented it.”

Vicenza public prosecutor

In his reply, the prosecutor suggested the court could instead weigh other charges, namely death as a consequence of another offence or abandonment of a minor, rather than wilful homicide with eventual intent. The defence asked for reclassification to culpable homicide together with the sentence discount, and the judges adopted that position. The final sentence is two years for each parent.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar