Safety · Valencia and Catarroja
Court rejects bid to force ex-government delegate Bernabé to hand over flood-day calls
Valencia's provincial court has upheld the refusal to order former government delegate Pilar Bernabé to hand over her communications from the day of the 2024 floods. The ruling is dated 12 November and was notified on Tuesday, 17 November.
AI text based on reports by europa press, LaVanguardia and eldiario.es. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The Audiencia de Valencia's second section rejected the appeals by Salomé Pradas and Emilio Argüeso, finding no usefulness or relevance in the requested communications from 29 October 2024. The ruling is dated 12 November.
Pilar Bernabé refused to hand over her phone when she testified as a witness on 14 April 2025, and the court said a broader request would meet the same refusal.
The court dismissed a private prosecution appeal seeking investigative steps after the testimony of mayor María José Catalá, calling the measures manifestly irrelevant and noting the Poyo ravine information was already in the case.
- July 2026Salomé Pradas asks the judge to order Bernabé and Miguel Polo to provide their communications
- 12 NovAudiencia de Valencia rules against the appeals and confirms the judge's refusal
- 17 NovThe ruling is notified
The appeal and the ruling
The second section of the Audiencia Provincial de Valencia dismissed appeals filed by former councillor Salomé Pradas and her former second-in-command Emilio Argüeso, who had served as the regional emergency secretary. The pair had asked that former government delegate Pilar Bernabé be made to hand over every communication she held on 29 October 2024 that related to the emergency. The floods that day left 234 dead in the province of Valencia, and both Pradas and Argüeso are under investigation in the case. The panel, deciding unanimously, backed the Catarroja investigating judge who had refused the request. The ruling is dated 12 November, and the court notified it on Tuesday, 17 November.
Why the court refused
The court found no usefulness or relevance in the evidence requested and pointed out that Bernabé had already declined to hand over her phone when she testified as a witness on 14 April 2025. According to the panel, demanding her phone records would strike at the core of her right to privacy, even if milder safeguards were proposed. The court described the request as generic and said it identified no specific communication that would justify it. Pradas and Argüeso also needed to explain which part of Bernabé's testimony incriminated them and how the records could challenge it, and the court said they did not do so. The panel further held that the reasoning for the refusal was sufficient, which rules out the claim that the defence's equality of arms had been breached.
“If the witness refused to hand over the list of calls, it can be inferred that she will equally refuse what the appellants now request, with far greater scope.”
Pradas had asked the judge in July 2026 to order Bernabé and the head of the Júcar Hydrographic Confederation, Miguel Polo, to provide voluntarily all communications from 29 October relating to the management of the emergency. The judge refused that request, and the Audiencia has now confirmed the refusal in full.
A second appeal on the Poyo ravine
The court also dismissed a separate appeal by a private prosecution against the judge's refusal to order a series of investigative steps after the testimony of Valencia mayor María José Catalá. The panel said most of the information sought about the state of the Poyo ravine and its overflow, which caused deaths in the village of La Torre, was already in the case file. The appellants had not shown what specific information about drainage, sanitation, the Albufera floodgates or pumping stations could count as critical hydrological information. The court called the requested measures manifestly irrelevant. It also recalled that the Cecopi was the only body with powers in emergency matters on the afternoon of the disaster.
Timeline of the dispute
The sequence runs from the floods of 29 October 2024 to the ruling notified this week. After two years of investigation, the court said it now applies stricter criteria to investigative steps than it did in the early phase, in order to avoid gathering superfluous, unnecessary or repeated information. The articles do not describe any further procedural step after the notified ruling.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- europa pressThe Court rejects the request of Pradas and Argüeso for Bernabé...L'Audiència rebutja la petició de Pradas i Argüeso perquè Bernabé... · original in Catalan
- europa pressThe Court rejects the request of Pradas and Argüeso for...La Audiencia rechaza la petición de Pradas y Argüeso para que... · original in Spanish
- LaVanguardiaThe Court rejects that Bernabé must show her messages from the day of the DANALa Audiencia rechaza que Bernabé deba mostrar sus mensajes del día de la dana · original in Spanish
- eldiario.esThe Valencia Court refuses to request the calls of the Government delegate during the DANA due to the right to privacyLa Audiencia de Valencia rechaza pedir las llamadas de la delegada del Gobierno en la dana por el derecho a la intimidad · original in Spanish
- María José Catalá
- Mayor of Valencia, whose witness testimony prompted the rejected investigative requests
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar