Diplomacy · Washington and Jerusalem
Trump's Israel aid cut on election day exposes a deepening US rift with Israel
On election day, Donald Trump said he would cut $3.8 billion in annual US military aid to Israel. Chicago Council polling shows American views of Israel at the lowest level recorded, with Democrats the most critical.
AI text based on reports by The Irish Times, NRC, wpolityce.pl and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
On 3 November, Donald Trump said on Fox News that he would cut the $3.8 billion in annual US military aid to Israel, which covers about a sixth of Israel's peacetime defence budget.
The Chicago Council score for Israel fell to 44 in October, down from 58 in 2022, and Democrats gave it only 30 points.
J.D. Vance blamed the Iran war for the Republican losses, while Abdul El-Sayed won a Michigan Senate seat despite AIPAC spending more than 63 million euros.
The aid decision depends on Congress, where Democrats now hold control, and the extension beyond 2028 was under negotiation before the announcement.
- 3 NovTrump says on Fox News he will cut $3.8 billion in annual US military aid to Israel, on election day
- 4 NovVance posts on X, implicitly naming support for Israel as a main cause of the Republican defeat
A remark on election day
On 3 November, the day of the US midterm elections, Donald Trump said on Fox News that he would cut the $3.8 billion in annual US military assistance to Israel. Israeli officials had believed they were negotiating an extension of a 10-year memorandum of understanding on US military aid, originally agreed under former president Barack Obama. The aid covers about a sixth of Israel's defence budget in peacetime, and the talks in Washington concerned an extension beyond 2028. A French-language account puts the planned reduction at roughly $4 billion for 2027, a figure that differs from the $3.8 billion cited elsewhere. Netanyahu has made his relationship with Trump the cornerstone of his political persona, which makes the public reversal especially painful for him.
A shift in American opinion
Dennis Ross, a former US negotiator with Israel, and Peter Welch, the Democratic senator for Vermont, both describe a "sea change" in relations between the two countries. Ross put the scale of the shift in numbers.
“The public in the United States always supported Israel. Now, for the first time, we have 60 per cent of the American public disapproving of Israel and its policy.”
The Chicago Council on Global Affairs has measured Americans' feelings toward Israel since 1978 on a scale from 0 to 100. Israel stayed between 53 and 61 points until 2022, when it scored 58. In the October poll it fell to 44, the lowest score recorded in the survey's history, and among Democrats it reached only 30. Dov Waxman, a professor of Israel studies at UCLA, said Democrats are mainly reacting to the treatment of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. Republicans, in his account, are angry that the Israeli-initiated attack on Iran does not serve American interests.
- 2022
- 58 points (0-100 scale)
- 2026-10 (all Americans)
- 44 points (0-100 scale)
- 2026-10 (Democrats)
- 30 points (0-100 scale)
Data from the article text
Midterms and the Iran war
Republicans suffered a midterm defeat far worse than their own expectations, and American anger over the US-Israeli war against Iran was one of the main factors. Abdul El-Sayed, a Michigan Democrat with a sharply critical message on Israel, won a US Senate seat despite AIPAC spending more than 63 million euros this election cycle. Unfounded Republican claims that he was a jihadist did not stick to him, and AIPAC's support for his opponents became a liability. Vice President J.D. Vance blamed the Iran war for the Republican losses, saying voters were tired of high prices and wanted a change in the relationship with Israel. On 4 November, the day after the vote, Vance posted on X, implicitly naming support for Israel as one of the main causes of the defeat.
What comes next
Trump's announcement does not settle the matter on its own, because the aid depends on Congress rather than the president. Negotiations over extending the memorandum beyond 2028 were under way before the remark. Democrats now control Congress, and some of the party's moderates also condemn Israel's actions. Whether the reduction takes effect in 2027 therefore depends on a Congress where Democrats hold control.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The Irish Times'People are appalled': How Israel lost America
- NRCThe warm bond between the US and Israel is under heavy pressure. “Israel has lost the American youth”De warme band tussen de VS en Israël staat zwaar onder druk. 'Israël is de Amerikaanse jeugd kwijtgeraakt' · original in Dutch
- wpolityce.plAmerica turns away from Israel. “This heralds a deep generational change”Ameryka odwraca się od Izraela. "To zwiastuje głęboką zmianę pokoleniową · original in Polish
- Courrier internationalIn Washington, the midterms mark the end of total support for IsraelÀ Washington, les midterms signent la fin du soutien total à Israël · original in French
- Donald Trump
- US president who announced the cut in military aid to Israel on election day
- Binyamin Netanyahu
- Israeli prime minister whose ties with Trump are central to his political image
- Dennis Ross
- Former US negotiator with Israel who describes a sea change in ties
- Peter Welch
- Democratic senator for Vermont who describes a sea change in US-Israel ties
- Barack Obama
- Former president under whom the 10-year military aid memorandum was originally agreed
- J.D. Vance
- US vice president who blamed the Iran war for the Republican defeat
- Abdul El-Sayed
- Democrat who won a US Senate seat in Michigan with a critical message on Israel
- Dov Waxman
- UCLA professor of Israel studies who explains the partisan shift in views of Israel
- Places
- Washington, United States, Jerusalem, Israel, Washington, D.C., Michigan
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar