Conflicts · Dublin, Abu Dhabi, and Geneva
US envoys float NATO membership for Ukraine in exchange for Donbas land, WSJ reports
Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have raised Ukrainian NATO membership in talks with Kyiv, European officials and Russian negotiators, according to a Wall Street Journal report published on 19 November 2026.
AI text based on reports by The Independent, Der Tagesspiegel and Deutsche Welle. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
According to the WSJ, Jared Kushner has suggested that Kyiv could join NATO if it gives up territory Russia demands, a proposal reported on 19 November 2026.
One scenario offers full NATO membership in exchange for all of Donbas, the other freezes the front line and keeps part of Donbas under Ukrainian control with US-backed guarantees.
A Russian negotiators' position paper seen by the WSJ demands that Ukraine's NATO aspiration be removed from its constitution.
Trump had previously called Ukrainian NATO membership unacceptable to Russia, and the WSJ report does not make clear whether he has changed his position.
- August 2026The idea reportedly first emerges, about six months after the Geneva talks ended
- Mid-November 2026 (Dublin)Kushner raises NATO membership with Zelensky and European security advisers
- Mid-November 2026 (Abu Dhabi)The idea is discussed at talks in Abu Dhabi
- 19 NovThe Wall Street Journal reports the two scenarios
A reversal in the peace talks
US envoys have floated the idea of NATO membership for Ukraine in closed-door talks, according to a Wall Street Journal report published on 19 November 2026 that cites people familiar with the negotiations. The idea has long been treated as a red line for Russia, which has opposed even NATO peacekeepers in a post-war settlement. Donald Trump himself ruled out Ukrainian membership in early 2025, so the proposal marks a shift that the report does not fully explain. Ukraine has said it cannot and will not give up control of its eastern lands, which are rich in minerals and host its line of fortress cities.
Two scenarios on the table
According to the WSJ, Jared Kushner has pushed two scenarios in recent negotiating rounds. In the first, Kyiv would give up the Donbas areas Russia already holds, along with the parts of Donbas it does not hold, in return for full NATO membership. In the second, the front lines would freeze, leaving part of the contested Donbas under Ukrainian control, with security guarantees written into an agreement with the United States and possibly European allies. A US official told the newspaper that many ideas are being discussed and that any final deal requires the consent of both Ukraine and Russia. The report leaves open how seriously Washington takes the proposal.
Where the idea has surfaced
The idea reportedly emerged in August, about six months after a round of talks in Geneva ended without a clear breakthrough. It came up again at a meeting involving Ukrainian, European and Russian negotiators in the United Arab Emirates, and the report does not say how the Kremlin responded. Tagesspiegel reports that Kushner raised it with Volodymyr Zelensky and European security advisers in Dublin in mid-November, and that the Abu Dhabi talks in mid-November also touched on it. Zelensky has confirmed that the question came up, and has repeatedly said that Ukraine does not intend to give up its territory and that any deal must be approved by the Ukrainian people.
Moscow's demands and the Trump factor
A position paper from the Russian negotiators, which the WSJ says it reviewed, demands that Ukraine's aspiration to join NATO be removed from its constitution. The report does not record the Kremlin's reaction to the NATO idea itself. Trump met Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China, in the week of 16 November 2026. Trump greeted the Russian leader with a question and a remark:
“Who is he? He's my friend”
The meeting came amid a growing rift between Washington and Europe since Trump returned to office. Trump has also cast doubt on whether he would defend a NATO ally under attack, saying last year that he would not defend countries that failed to meet his "requirements" on defence spending.
Why the security question matters
The United States, Russia and the United Kingdom gave security assurances in 1994 when Ukraine gave up its nuclear weapons, but those assurances did not stop Russia annexing Crimea in 2014 or launching a full-scale invasion in 2022. NATO membership could go some way toward the security guarantees Ukraine wants against a future invasion. An attack on NATO without the United States, the bloc's largest contributor, would leave Europe and Canada a weakened force against any potential adversary.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The IndependentUS offers Ukraine Nato membership for land swap with Russia: report
- Der TagesspiegelSurprising US push: Why NATO membership for Ukraine is suddenly back on the tableÜberraschender US-Vorstoß: Warum plötzlich wieder eine Nato-Mitgliedschaft der Ukraine im Raum steht · original in German
- Deutsche WelleWSJ: US discusses Ukraine's accession to NATO in exchange for DonbasWSJ: США обсуждают вступление Украины в НАТО в обмен на Донбасс · original in Russian
- Jared Kushner
- Trump's son-in-law, reportedly pushing the NATO-for-land idea in talks
- Steve Witkoff
- US envoy who reportedly discussed the NATO-for-land idea in negotiations
- Donald Trump
- US president whose envoys reportedly floated the proposal
- Volodymyr Zelensky
- Ukrainian president who confirmed the question came up in talks
- Vladimir Putin
- Russian president who met Trump at the APEC summit in Shenzhen
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar