Diplomacy · New York and Shenzhen

UN Security Council vote on 20 November tests Grynspan's bid to succeed Guterres

Eight candidates are seeking to succeed António Guterres as UN secretary-general. On Friday, 20 November, the 15-member Security Council holds a colour-coded straw poll in which the five permanent members vote on red ballots and the ten elected members on white.

AI text based on reports by il Giornale.it, Financial Times News, The Guardian and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: UNCTAD, CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons, cropped). File photo, 2025
How it came to this
  1. 30 JulFirst secret straw poll of the Security Council
  2. 20 NovColour-coded vote with P5 on red and elected members on white ballots
  3. 31 DecGuterres's second term ends
  4. 1 JanSuccessor's five-year term begins

The race and its deadline

Guterres's second term ends on 31 December 2026, and his successor takes office on 1 January 2027 for a five-year term. Eight candidates have been formally put forward by member states: Rebeca Grynspan (Costa Rica), Rafael Mariano Grossi (Argentina), María Fernanda Espinosa Garcés and Ivonne A-Baki (Ecuador), Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett (Guyana), Olara Otunnu (Uganda), Lana Zaki Nusseibeh (United Arab Emirates) and Feridun Hadi Sinirlioğlu (Turkey). Under Article 97 of the UN Charter, the Security Council recommends one candidate, which requires at least nine votes and no veto from the five permanent members, before the General Assembly makes the formal appointment. The Council has held eight earlier straw polls with uniform white ballots, the first secret ballot took place on 30 July, and the Guardian describes the deadlock as lasting 140 days.

What the colour-coded ballot will show

The ballot on 20 November at 12:00 New York time (18:00 Italian time) introduces a new format. The five permanent members, the United States, Russia, China, France and the United Kingdom, will cast red ballots, while the ten elected members will use white. Objections from states holding a veto can therefore be told apart from objections by the other members, and the Guardian says the result could reveal whether the Costa Rican frontrunner will be blocked by the big powers. The Financial Times reports that the vote was delayed by 24 hours, which gave P5 diplomats attending the summit in Shenzhen more time to haggle over the future of the UN. One unnamed diplomat said that the number of votes a candidate wins matters, but so does how many of certain votes the candidate avoids losing.

Grynspan's position

Rebeca Grynspan, 70, is an economist and former Costa Rican vice-president who would be the first woman and the first Jewish secretary-general. The FT reports that she has temporarily stepped aside as head of the UN trade body. She has led in all but one of the eight straw polls, and in the last one she received 12 approval votes and three disapprovals. The FT says the three disapprovals are widely believed to include the United States and Russia, while the Guardian reports that Russia and the US are thought to have resisted her candidacy. In an interview with the Financial Times, Grynspan said she had won the campaign and now had to win the election, referring to the votes of the P5.

Grynspan's votes in the last straw pollvotes
Approval
12 votes
Disapproval
3 votes

Data from the article text

Nusseibeh and the UAE campaign

Lana Zaki Nusseibeh entered the race late and has contested two straw polls so far. In those two polls she secured seven encourage votes, six discourage votes and two no opinions. The Guardian reports that her campaign has prestigious big-power backing, yet the UAE's active, commercially driven diplomacy draws hostility in Sudan, Somalia, Western Sahara, Libya and Yemen. The ballot on 20 November may show whether that hostility will undermine her campaign.

Lana Zaki Nusseibeh, two straw polls combinedvotes
Encourage
7 votes
Discourage
6 votes
No opinion
2 votes

Data from the article text

Calls for a stronger UN

Der Tagesspiegel reports that the UN is short of money because many member states have not paid their contributions and international aid has been cut, partly as defence spending rises. The Security Council is largely blocked over the wars in Ukraine and Iran because the interests of its veto powers diverge. According to the FT, all the candidates argue that the organisation must return to its founding mission of 1945 as an arbiter of global peace. Daniel Forti, a UN expert at the International Crisis Group, commented on the delay:

“It is worrying that the council has not yet made a decision, especially now, when the UN needs focused leadership and strong political support.”

Daniel Forti

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Organizations
United Nations
New York, Shenzhen · United States, China

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar