Safety · London
UK peers warn government complacent over resilience, urge cabinet minister for emergencies
A House of Lords committee says ministers are complacent about threats from cyber-attacks to undersea cable sabotage. The report, published on Monday, 16 November 2026, calls for a resilience minister.
AI text based on reports by The Guardian, LBC, BBC and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The committee says the government appears complacent and the UK underprepared, despite the Be Ready campaign launched in October.
Peers want a cabinet minister solely for resilience appointed within six months, plus an annual prime ministerial statement to parliament.
Ministers want to switch off DTT as soon as 2034, while an estimated 220,000 homes would still lack broadband by the mid-2030s.
About 95% of UK food sold is controlled by 12 retailers, and the bulk of antibiotic medicines are made in China or India.
- July 2026Angela Eagle, then security minister, tells the committee the government did not want to frighten people
- October 2026Government launches the Be Ready campaign urging households to stock up
- 16 NovLords National Resilience Committee publishes its report calling the government complacent
Ministers accused of complacency
A House of Lords committee on national resilience says ministers are complacent about threats that are growing more interconnected, and that the UK is underprepared for crises ranging from cyber-attacks and sabotage to extreme weather and flooding. The committee chair, Baroness Jean Coussins, argues the public is not the problem, since people have been stocking up on bottled water, tinned food and wind-up radios. What is missing, she writes, is candour from the government about the rising frequency of threats. In July, Angela Eagle, then security minister, told the committee that the government did not want to "frighten people", a stance the peers say leaves the public ill prepared.
“In the face of potentially catastrophic risks and despite the recent launch of the Be Ready campaign, the government appears complacent and the UK is underprepared.”
What the committee wants
The peers want a cabinet minister responsible solely for resilience, appointed within six months, because current arrangements lack the seniority the task requires. They also want the prime minister to make an annual statement to parliament on how prepared the country is. Every household would receive a booklet on preparing for and responding to an emergency, following models used in Denmark and Sweden. The report proposes a new "civic resilience leave" that would give workers paid time off for approved training and emergency volunteering, without recommending an exact entitlement. Eligibility for the armed forces "gap year" scheme would extend to 16 to 24-year-olds not in employment, education or training, and water companies would have to show they can keep emergency supplies flowing through prolonged outages.
Food, medicine and cascading threats
The committee says the UK's emergency plans are often out of date and deal with single emergencies in isolation, rather than a polycrisis in which one disruption triggers the next. Supply chains are a particular weakness, since about 95% of food sold in the UK is controlled by 12 retailers. The peers note that the bulk of antibiotic medicines are made in China or India, and that the UK no longer has any domestic antibiotic manufacturers. They accept that an eight-week "buffer stock" requirement for certain medicines offers important protection, but ask whether it provides sufficient coverage. The committee also warns of "grey zone" hostility from Russia, China and Iran, including cyberattacks, proxy acts of violence and sabotage of undersea cables and pipelines.
Freeview and emergency communication
Ministers want to switch off digital terrestrial TV (DTT) broadcasts, received through household aerials, as soon as 2034 as more viewers move to streaming. The committee calls the plan a threat to national security and wants it scrapped, arguing that broadcast masts could be the only reliable way to send emergency messages if a cyberattack caused an internet blackout. An estimated 220,000 homes would still lack broadband by the mid-2030s, and ministers are considering whether the switch-off should slip to 2044. The peers say a forced move to internet-only TV could cost some households an extra £218 a year for high-speed broadband. Coussins told The i Paper that pensioners and other vulnerable groups could lose a key channel of communication.
“In a national emergency, access to reliable information can be a lifeline.”
Power grid under pressure
In an interview with the Financial Times, National Grid chief executive Zoë Yujnovich discussed how the grid stays running under sabotage and cyber threats. She sidestepped a question about her role in the government's stockpiling advice, drawing a comparison with running a corporation. Across England and Wales, the network runs 236,000km of overhead and underground lines. Yujnovich said the company can often fix power failures in minutes or even seconds, and that three days should be enough to repair the most extreme assault on the system. Its six interconnectors with continental Europe and two planned cables between Scotland and East Anglia are among its most obvious points of vulnerability to sabotage, given Russia's apparent attacks on subsea cables.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The GuardianPrep for disaster, ministers said - and millions stocked up. It's the UK government that's not ready | Jean Coussins
- The GuardianUK exposed to polycrisis of threats amid government 'complacency'
- LBCUK 'seriously underprepared' for emergencies and threats such as cyberattacks and extreme weather, resilience group warns
- BBCWorkers should get paid time off to train for national crises, say peers
- Jean Coussins
- Baroness and chair of the Lords National Resilience Committee
- Angela Eagle
- Former security minister who told the committee in July that the government did not want to frighten people
- Places
- London, United Kingdom, Great Britain, Denmark, Iran, China
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar