Climate · London and Edinburgh
UK climate adviser warns weakening EV sales mandate would put net zero targets at risk
The Climate Change Committee says the UK would likely miss legally binding climate targets if the zero emission vehicle mandate is weakened, while the government reviews a cut to the 2030 target.
AI text based on reports by Evening Standard, The Telegraph, POLITICO and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The Climate Change Committee says the UK is likely to miss legally binding climate targets if the mandate is weakened, with the changes adding an estimated 8.4m tonnes of CO2 a year by the next decade.
The 2030 target of 80% is under review and could fall to as low as 50%, with a decision expected by the end of 2026 and departments at odds over the outcome.
Electric cars made up 26.6% of UK new car sales in the first 10 months of 2026, below the 33% headline target, though carmakers are expected to comply using flexibilities.
Stephen Flynn says any change needs agreement from all four nations, while SMMT chief executive Mike Hawes says the industry cannot subsidise the transition indefinitely.
- August 2026Consultation on changes to the interim targets begins
- 18 NovCommittee chair's letter to the Transport Secretary published
- End of 2026Decision on the mandate expected
What the climate adviser warned
On Wednesday, 18 November 2026, the Climate Change Committee published a letter from its chair, Nigel Topping, to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander. The committee is the independent body that advises the government on climate policy. Topping argued that weakening the zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate would leave the UK likely to miss its legally binding climate targets. The mandate currently requires 80% of new cars sold to be zero emission by 2030, with all new cars meeting that standard by 2035. Companies that fall short face a potential fine of £12,000 per car, although there are exemptions. The committee's analysis says the mandate underpins the largest share of emissions reduction to 2037, and that the 2033-2037 targets would be missed without alternative action on the same scale. It estimates the proposed changes could add 8.4m tonnes of CO2 pollution a year by the next decade.
Household costs and oil exposure
Topping wrote that keeping the existing rules could reduce costs for a typical household by around £800 a year, as drivers switch from petrol to electric cars. He pointed to a government impact assessment, cited in the letter, which suggests that cutting the headline targets would raise UK fuel consumption by up to 15 million barrels of oil a year by 2030. Topping put the cost of that extra oil at current prices in the following terms:
“At current prices, this would cost the U.K. more than £1 billion.”
The committee also warned that changes could leave van drivers exposed to high diesel prices and could weaken investment in the UK car sector, where EV sales already trail Germany and France. Topping added that weaker rules would damage long-term competitiveness as the UK's main export markets move to electric vehicles.
Government position and the review
A government spokesperson said ministers remain committed to ending new petrol and diesel car sales by 2030, that new cars and vans sold should be zero emission by 2035, and that the UK's legally binding net zero targets still stand. The spokesperson said the consultation on the mandate would not alter those commitments. Government sources maintain that nothing has been decided, and the consultation on the interim targets dates from August. The government is reviewing whether to cut the 2030 target from 80% to as low as 50%, under pressure from carmakers who have lobbied for reductions to 50% or 60%. According to several government and industry figures involved in the discussions, the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero wants to keep the mandate, while the Business and Trade Department wants it reduced. A decision is expected by the end of the year.
Industry and Scottish reaction
Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, accused the committee of ignoring the costs of the targets it defends, saying:
“The industry cannot subsidise the transition indefinitely, which is why it is unified in seeking change.”
The SMMT says fully electric cars made up 26.6% of new car registrations so far this year, below the headline target of 33% for 2026. Analysis by New AutoMotive, a transport research organisation that supports the switch to electric cars, suggests the industry as a whole is on course to comply with this year's mandate once flexibilities are counted.
- First 10 months of 2026, electric share
- 26.6 %
- 2026 headline target
- 33 %
Data from the article text
In Scotland, Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn called any weakening of the mandate "wholly unacceptable" and said the policy depends on devolved legislation. He said:
“This policy depends on devolved legislation and can only be changed with the express agreement of the Governments and parliaments of all four nations.”
Scottish ministers oppose any rollback, arguing it would raise prices for consumers during a cost-of-living crisis and weaken efforts to cut vehicle emissions.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Evening StandardWatering down EV mandate would be 'wholly unacceptable', says Stephen Flynn
- The TelegraphGovernment climate adviser warns Labour against watering down EV targets
- POLITICOClimate advisers warn UK ministers: Don't meddle with electric vehicle rules
- BBCCutting EV target risks UK missing climate targets, warns adviser
- Heidi Alexander
- Transport Secretary who received the Climate Change Committee letter
- Stephen Flynn
- Scotland's Transport Secretary who opposes weakening the mandate
- Siân Berry
- Green Party transport spokesperson quoted on the mandate debate
- Places
- London, United Kingdom, Edinburgh, Great Britain
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar