Football · Brussels and Nyon

Union of European Clubs files EU complaint against UEFA and EFC pact, citing competition law

The Union of European Clubs has asked the European Commission to investigate whether UEFA's recognition of EFC as the sole body representing clubs breaches EU competition rules.

AI text based on reports by Mediafax.ro, The Guardian, The New York Times and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Brussels, Nyon · Belgium, Switzerland
How it came to this
  1. 2008UEFA and EFC first agree the memorandum of understanding
  2. October 2024Memorandum renewed until July 2033
  3. 16 NovUEC files complaint with the European Commission

Complaint filed in Brussels

The Union of European Clubs (UEC) filed a complaint with the European Commission on Monday, 16 November, targeting the memorandum of understanding between UEFA and European Football Clubs (EFC). The UEC asks the Commission to examine whether the arrangement breaks Articles 101 and 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which prohibit anti-competitive agreements and abuse of a dominant position. Under the memorandum, UEFA recognises EFC as the sole body representing European clubs. According to The New York Times, the pact was first agreed in 2008 and renewed in October 2024 until July 2033. The UEC was set up in 2023 to represent non-elite clubs, and The Guardian counts 138 members from 25 national associations, while The New York Times puts it at more than 140 clubs from 25 nations.

What the UEC alleges

The UEC says exclusive recognition, combined with unequal voting rights inside EFC, lets a small group of leading clubs influence access to European competitions, the calendar and the distribution of revenue. Mediafax reports that EFC nominates 16 of the 20 members of UEFA's Club Competitions Committee, the body that reviews changes to formats, qualification and prize money. The Guardian adds that clubs may not join another cross-border club association without permission from EFC and UEFA, and that EFC told at least one club its membership would be terminated if it also stayed with the UEC. According to the complaint, 59 UEC member clubs asked on joining that their membership not be made public, citing concern about pressure. Dennis Gudasic, the UEC general secretary and CEO of Lokomotiva Zagreb, framed the dispute in one question.

“The question is simple: who gets a say in the rules that shape every club's future?”

Dennis Gudasic

Membership and the wider case

EFC was previously known as the European Club Association (ECA). Mediafax puts its membership above 900 across men's and women's football, while The Guardian reports it is closing in on 1,000 after a recent recruitment drive. The UEC argues that these numbers do not bring equal voting rights, despite a series of recent reforms, according to The Guardian. The UEC also cites a sector that moves 40,000 million euros a year, and The Independent reports that about 50 clubs have taken four of every five Champions League places since 2000. Under the current distribution, clubs in UEFA competitions receive the majority of a total revenue pot of 4.4 billion euros, according to The New York Times. The complaint was prepared with advice from Miguel Poiares Maduro, a former advocate general at the Court of Justice of the European Union, who described the case in these terms.

“This case is about using European competition law to protect the European sports model of genuinely open and balanced competitions.”

Miguel Poiares Maduro, former advocate general at the Court of Justice of the EU

Brussels reaction and the stakes

POLITICO reports that DG Competition, the Commission's antitrust enforcement arm, has historically been reluctant to open soccer investigations, viewing them as politically toxic, according to current and former senior officials. Relations between UEFA and the Commission are described as warm, after President Aleksander Čeferin and EU Sports Commissioner Glenn Micallef renewed a cooperation arrangement at a meeting in Nyon, Switzerland, in the week of 9 November. Relations with FIFA are described as frostier, yet the Commission has been hesitant to open a formal probe into its international match calendar, despite pressure from European lawmakers. The Independent notes that the close relationship between Čeferin and EFC chairman Nasser Al-Khelaifi has come under scrutiny, and that EFC plans global expansion as a third power in football beside FIFA and UEFA. The same outlet cites a commissioned study showing English clubs received 110 million euros in UEFA prize money in a single season, half the entire revenue of clubs such as Fulham, Crystal Palace and Everton.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Brussels, Nyon

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar