Diplomacy · Shenzhen, Pyongyang, and Panmunjom

Trump leaves China without meeting Kim Jong Un, citing a crowded schedule

Trump left China on Thursday, 19 November, without meeting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un despite days of speculation. He said the two would meet at some point, while experts doubt Pyongyang will engage.

AI text based on reports by 20minutes, lastampa.it, Mediafax.ro and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Shenzhen, Pyongyang, Panmunjom · China, North Korea, South Korea
How it came to this
  1. 30 JunTrump steps over the concrete line at the DMZ to meet Kim at Panmunjom after a public invitation.
  2. 16 NovTrump suggests a surprise Kim meeting could happen on the sidelines of the APEC summit.
  3. 19 NovTrump leaves China without meeting Kim, citing a crowded schedule.

A meeting that never happened

Donald Trump left China on Thursday, 19 November, without meeting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, despite days of signals from the US president that a meeting was possible. Speaking aboard Air Force One to NBC News correspondent Gabe Gutierrez, Trump said the relationship exists but the two had not met. He cited a crowded schedule, saying there had been too many meetings for one to work, and added that they would meet at some point. Earlier that week he had said Kim would like to meet him. On Monday, 16 November, Trump suggested a surprise meeting could take place on the sidelines of the APEC summit, where Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin also took part.

Signs that stirred rumours

Speculation grew after reporters travelling with Trump had their phones taken on leaving China, a step described as being for security reasons. Social media users then spotted a temporary flight restriction over Alaska, which they linked to a refuelling landing for Air Force One. Kim was largely out of public view that week, with propaganda footage showing him at the foot of Mount Paektu watching his daughter ski. On the day Trump arrived in Shenzhen, Kim reviewed naval academy students on North Korea's east coast.

Why the logistics did not line up

Diplomats on both sides reportedly explained that without preparatory exchanges, a meeting would have required agreeing on a venue, protocol and security. The window between a stop in Manila and a trilateral with Xi and Putin was measured in hours. Kim prefers travelling by armoured train, and Shenzhen lies at the southern edge of China. Beijing could have provided an aircraft, as it did for Singapore in 2018, but it would also have had to decide whether to host the scene.

Experts and Pyongyang's conditions

Lim Eul-chul, a professor at Kyungnam University's Institute for Far Eastern Studies in South Korea, doubts that concrete contacts have taken place behind the scenes between Pyongyang and Washington. He argues that after the failed Hanoi summit in 2019, Kim probably concluded the United States was untrustworthy under either party. Koh Yu-hwan, an emeritus professor at Dongguk University in Seoul, said Kim had no reason to join a photo opportunity showcasing Trump's political achievements without preparation. Experts consider it very unlikely Pyongyang will respond to Trump's overtures unless Washington takes concrete steps to recognise North Korea as a nuclear-armed state. Kim had earlier indicated he would talk if the US dropped its hostile policy and respected North Korea's nuclear status. In early November, Kim Yo Jong, his influential sister, said Pyongyang had no reason to resume dialogue with a hostile United States.

Trump's record with Kim

Trump met Kim three times during his first term, in Singapore in 2018, in Hanoi in 2019 and at the Korean Demilitarised Zone. The Hanoi summit ended without an agreement, and the meetings aimed at curbing North Korea's nuclear programme produced no deal. The DMZ meeting took place on 30 June 2019, after a public invitation from Trump, when he stepped over the concrete line dividing the two Koreas and became the first sitting president to set foot in the North. In August he had announced he wanted to meet Kim before the end of this year.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar