Diplomacy · Shenzhen and Washington

Trump says Putin agreed Ukraine war would not have started if he were president

At a White House press conference on Friday, 20 November, Trump called the Shenzhen summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin a success and said the three countries would hold talks on reducing nuclear risks.

AI text based on reports by Mediafax.ro, Ziare.com, Libertatea and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Shenzhen, Washington · China, United States
How it came to this
  1. 19 NovBeijing publishes a four-point declaration attributed to Trump, Putin and Xi
  2. 19 November, eveningTrump dances to 'YMCA' at Xi's official banquet in Shenzhen
  3. 20 NovTrump holds a White House press conference on the Shenzhen summit

Shenzhen summit and the Friday briefing

Trump returned from China after a meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin held on the margins of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, which he described as the first trilateral meeting between the leaders of the United States, Russia and China. At a White House press conference on Friday, 20 November, he called the trip one of the most successful presidential visits to Asia in American history, and said he had travelled with Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio. He also rated the three-leader meeting 12 out of 10. On Thursday, 19 November, in the evening, Trump danced to the Village People hit 'YMCA' at an official banquet hosted by Xi, while young Chinese performers sang the song; White House communications adviser Margo Martin posted the video on X.

Putin, Ukraine and critics of the ties

Trump said Putin told him the 2022 invasion of Ukraine would never have happened had Trump been president at the time. He said he asked Putin directly whether Russia would have invaded if he had been in office, and that Putin answered that it would never have happened. Trump also linked the war to the 2020 election, saying it would not have happened had the election not been rigged and he had not been forced to wait four years, a claim he repeats whenever he discusses Ukraine. He said Putin wants to end the war through diplomacy and that the chances of success are high, while adding that Zelenski and Putin hate each other enormously, so the war is not over. Trump called Putin his friend, described the relationship as very good, and called people who criticise his ties to Putin and Xi stupid, saying some of them were in the room. Asked whether the Shenzhen meeting resembled the 1945 Yalta Conference, he said he had not thought about it and had simply gone there believing he got along well with both leaders and that their differences would be settled. Rubio defended such meetings, calling the idea that the three leaders should not meet regularly dangerous, because the three countries hold the overwhelming majority of nuclear weapons.

The four-point declaration and nuclear risk

Beijing published on Thursday, 19 November, a document attributed to Trump, Putin and Xi, setting out the commitments of the three leaders at the close of the summit. Its first point covers support for reform of the United Nations, with China, Russia and the United States as permanent Security Council members. The other points cover increasing the production and supply of refined petroleum products, respecting the immunity of state officials while limiting the International Criminal Court's intervention, and a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation. Trump highlighted the nuclear dialogue and said China is expanding its nuclear arsenal rapidly and could catch up with the United States in about ten years. He acknowledged that a nuclear arms limitation agreement will be difficult to reach, while saying he supports reducing nuclear risks. On Iran, he said he wants a real deal with Tehran rather than a fake one, claiming Iranian authorities have avoided an acceptable agreement for 51 years, and that both Putin and Xi want the conflict to end.

AI, data centres and trade

Trump said he had agreed with Xi on joint protection measures and rules for developing artificial intelligence, without giving details. In the same remarks he said US companies will not be allowed to build AI data centres abroad and threatened very high taxes on firms that choose to do so, arguing that China would otherwise take them all. A US official had told Reuters that Washington was preparing to ask dozens of countries to choose a side in the AI race, warning that countries joining China's framework would be removed from a US-led AI coalition. Local opposition to data centres centres on water use for cooling, rising electricity demand, and lawsuits over noise at sites in Michigan, Wisconsin and Arizona. More than 600 public objections were filed against a planned data centre in Kogan, Australia. Trump also cited trade agreements worth more than $17 billion that he said would benefit thousands of American workers.

What remains unclear

Trump said he had resolved disagreements with China and Russia but did not name any specific outcomes of the talks. He did not give a date for the data centre restriction and said he had not yet communicated the plan to his own officials. The declaration sets out talks on nuclear risk but no timetable for them appears in the reporting. Trump's assessment of the summit at 12 out of 10 rests on his own judgment, while the Ukraine and Iran questions remain open.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar