Football · Bruges and Tubize

Club Brugge seeks forfeit over Anderlecht's five-player Topper team sheet

The Belgian Football Union's disciplinary council heard the Topper case on Friday, 20 November, and will rule within a month at most. Anderlecht named five Belgian or assimilated players in the 1-1 draw, one short of the six required.

AI text based on reports by La Libre.be, Le Soir and 7sur7. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Bruges, Tubize · Belgium
How it came to this
  1. 8 NovTopper ends 1-1 with Anderlecht listing five Belgian or assimilated players instead of six
  2. 20 NovDisciplinary council hears both clubs and Union Saint-Gilloise, then takes the case under deliberation
  3. Within one month of 20 NovemberCouncil decision due

Hearing held on Friday

The disciplinary council of the Belgian Football Union heard the case on Friday, 20 November, about two weeks after the Topper between Club Brugge and Anderlecht ended 1-1 at the Jan Breydel Stadium on 8 November. Anderlecht had listed only five Belgian or assimilated players on its team sheet, one short of the six the rules require. Club Brugge filed the complaint. The hearing lasted more than an hour and was held by video link from Tubize, in Dutch, with lawyers for Brugge, Anderlecht and Union Saint-Gilloise present.

Brugge want a forfeit

Club Brugge's lawyer, Thomas Delameilleure, asked the council to impose a forfeit on Anderlecht and said the rule is more than a simple piece of paper. Brugge argue that the regulation is clear and must be applied even though the error was unintentional. A forfeit would award them the three points of a win and return them to the top of the table. Anderlecht's lawyer, Pieter Braeckman, disputed Brugge's standing in the case, saying the club acted in its own interest rather than in the interest of Belgian football, and left that question to the council. Anderlecht has stressed that the error was not deliberate. Under the rules, the club faces a points deduction, a forfeit or a fine.

Braeckman's central point was that the missing player changed nothing on the pitch.

“It is very hypothetical to say that the missing Belgian player on the team sheet influenced the final score.”

Pieter Braeckman

The defence pointed to goalkeeper Justin Heekeren, who sits behind Colin Coosemans, the keeper the defence says almost always plays full matches. It argued that a goalkeeper change had no real chance of happening, and that using the third, Belgian keeper instead would have kept the sheet compliant. Braeckman also called a forfeit or points deduction disproportionate.

Union Saint-Gilloise and a possible appeal

Union Saint-Gilloise asked to join the case as an interested party, arguing it would lose out if Brugge received the points. Its lawyer, Dimitri Dedecker, addressed the council members directly.

“Club Brugge are not asking for a sanction, they want a gift.”

Dimitri Dedecker

Dedecker added that two extra points for Brugge would not punish Anderlecht, the club at fault, and would reward Brugge at the expense of another club, Union Saint-Gilloise. If the council rules, Union Saint-Gilloise could access the file and appeal. Any appeal would be heard by the Belgian Court of Arbitration for Sport, the CBAS.

Verdict due within a month

The council did not rule on Friday. It said it would take the case under deliberation and decide within a month at most. The sequence so far runs from the 8 November match to Friday's hearing, with the decision still to come.

The verdict will settle whether Club Brugge's forfeit request succeeds and whether any appeal follows.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Bruges, Tubize

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar