Safety · IJmuiden and Amsterdam
Prosecutors charge Tata Steel with deliberate air pollution as Amsterdam trial opens
The Amsterdam court heard the opening session on Friday, 20 November, in a case alleging that Tata Steel let raw coke ignite 598 times between 2018 and 2025 at its IJmuiden plants.
AI text based on reports by Telegraaf, de Volkskrant, gelderlander.nl and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The OM accuses Tata Steel of five criminal offences linked to two coke-oven gas plants, including deliberate emission of harmful substances and a breach of its duty of care.
Between 2018 and 2025 the OM counted 598 cases in which Tata allegedly let raw coke ignite, and in three cases it allegedly failed to report this.
The OM has not decided whether individual executives or former board members will be prosecuted and expects to answer in early 2027.
Tata says the OM misinterpreted its data, calls the file unbalanced and wants 29 witnesses heard and judges to visit the site.
- July 2026The OM decides to prosecute Tata Steel
- 20 NovOpening session at the Amsterdam district court
- Early 2027The OM expects to decide on prosecuting executives
The charges
The Amsterdam district court opened the criminal case against Tata Steel on Friday, 20 November, with a preliminary hearing that drew dozens of residents and journalists. The Openbaar Ministerie (OM), the Dutch public prosecution service, decided in July of this year to bring the case. It accuses the IJmuiden steelmaker of five criminal offences linked to its two coke-oven gas plants, including deliberate emission of harmful substances that could affect public health, and a breach of its duty of care. The case grew out of a complaint filed in 2021 by lawyer Bénédicte Ficq on behalf of residents, although the reported number differs by outlet: 800 according to de Volkskrant, nearly 1,100 according to Gelderlander and 1,200 according to NOS.
How the coke plants allegedly polluted
Coal is heated to about 1,000 degrees in the coke-oven plants until its gas escapes, and the remaining coke is later used to make steel. According to the OM, when an oven is opened too early, while gas is still inside, the raw coke can catch fire and release toxic substances. Between 2018 and 2025 the OM counted 598 cases in which Tata allegedly let this happen, and in three cases the company allegedly failed to report it although reporting is mandatory. The prosecution also says Tata neglected its duty of care by not maintaining furnace burners in time, leaving damaged walls unrepaired and not carrying out its maintenance plan properly for years. Soot deposits containing substances of serious concern have been found on window sills, cars and children's playgrounds close to the plant. The national institute RIVM records an above-average number of lung cancer cases in the IJmond area.
Evidence gathering
Investigators from the Inspectie Leefomgeving en Transport, the DCMR Rijnmond environmental agency and the Netherlands Forensic Institute entered the plant site about eighteen months after the complaint, and data was seized at the head office. During the investigation the OM tapped telephones, including those of employees, hacked Tata's network and computers and made secret video recordings, according to Gelderlander. De Volkskrant reports that such powers are normally permitted by the investigating judge only for serious crimes. The OM also visited the factories repeatedly, measured the amount of harmful substances in the air and heard witnesses. Almost five years passed between the complaint and the decision to prosecute.
Tata's defence
Tata denies that there was any danger to public health. The company says the OM gathered a great deal of information but interpreted the data incorrectly, and it calls the criminal file unbalanced. One of Tata's lawyers argued that the investigation team examined the coke process without specialist knowledge in-house. The company wants 29 people heard as witnesses and wants the judges to visit the site to see the process for themselves. Earlier on Friday, Tata tried to have the entire case dropped, objecting to the way the OM carried out its investigation. Ficq, who attended the hearing, called the day extremely important and said it concerns a serious offence.
“Polluters must realise that pollution that makes people ill can be criminal.”
Executives and public reaction
Whether individual executives or former board members face prosecution remains undecided, and the OM expects to answer that question in early 2027. A Telegraaf reader poll shows the public divided. Just over half of participants do not think Tata should be prosecuted for air pollution. On whether the health of residents weighs more than jobs, 44 percent said yes and 38 percent said no. Almost 57 percent said managers should not be prosecuted personally, and 55 percent opposed revoking the permit for the coke-oven plants, against 31 percent in favour.
- Health outweighs jobs: yes
- 44 %
- Health outweighs jobs: no
- 38 %
- Executives should not be prosecuted (almost 57%)
- 57 %
- Against revoking coke-plant permit
- 55 %
- For revoking coke-plant permit
- 31 %
Data from the article text
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- TelegraafReaders critical of Tata Steel prosecutionLezers kritisch over vervolging Tata Steel · original in Dutch
- de VolkskrantOM: Tata released toxic substances hundreds of times without a permitOM: Tata liet zonder vergunning honderden keren giftige stoffen vrijkomen · original in Dutch
- gelderlander.nlInvestigators hacked Tata Steel computers to obtain informationRecherche hackte computers Tata Steel om informatie te acherhalen · original in Dutch
- NOSCriminal case against Tata Steel for “deliberate air pollution” beginsStrafzaak tegen Tata Steel om 'opzettelijke luchtvervuiling' van start · original in Dutch
- Places
- Netherlands, Amsterdam
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar