Government · Penafiel, Amarante, and Aveiro

Tâmega e Sousa health chief would request exit if definitively indicted

José Luís Gaspar, head of the Tâmega e Sousa health unit, says he will request dismissal if a definitive indictment is brought over alleged corruption while he led Amarante council. The health ministry has kept him in post, unlike the Aveiro health unit chief it dismissed after a detention.

AI text based on reports by PÚBLICO, SIC Notícias and Notícias ao Minuto. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Penafiel, Amarante, Aveiro, Portimão · Portugal
How it came to this
  1. 30 SeptProsecution's accusation against Gaspar made public
  2. 12 NovMinistry of Health says the Tâmega e Sousa case differs from Aveiro
  3. 13 NovGaspar says he will request dismissal if a definitive indictment is brought

The charges

José Luís Gaspar, president of the Unidade Local de Saúde (ULS) do Tâmega e Sousa, is accused of two counts of prevarication and one count of passive corruption. Prosecutors allege the acts took place between 2013 and 2017, when he was president of the Amarante municipal council. The accusation was made public on 30 September, yet Gaspar remains in his post at the health unit, which is based in Penafiel. His statement notes that prosecutors did not ask for his public functions to be suspended. The case now moves into the instruction phase, an optional stage in which an investigating judge decides whether it goes to trial and on what terms.

The ministry's reasoning

The Ministry of Health was asked about the difference in treatment and answered on Thursday, 12 November. In its view, the Aveiro case carried a risk of harming the organisation and running of that health unit, a risk it says does not exist in Tâmega e Sousa because the suspicions concern duties Gaspar no longer holds. The ministry also stressed that judicial questions belong to the courts and that everyone is presumed innocent until a court rules. It said Minister Ana Paula Martins takes decisions in the areas she is mandated for, and that her job is to protect patients across the hospital units. The ministry put its position on the presumption of innocence this way:

“Judicial decisions belong to the courts, and everyone enjoys the presumption of innocence.”

Ministry of Health

Gaspar's response

Gaspar issued a six-point statement on Friday, 13 November, sending it to newsrooms and to the news agency Lusa. He says he has always cooperated with uncovering the truth and is fully convinced of his total innocence. He argues that no definitive indictment exists yet and that, in a democratic state governed by law, judges decide acquittal or conviction at trial. He also says he will keep carrying out his duties until then, while acknowledging that a definitive indictment would oblige him to prepare a trial defence. He set out his conditional exit in these terms:

“If a definitive indictment is brought, I myself will request dismissal from the post I currently hold.”

José Luís Gaspar

Some coverage frames the trigger differently. SIC described it as being committed for trial (pronunciado), while the quoted statement refers to a definitive indictment.

The Aveiro and Algarve dismissals

The treatment of the Aveiro case stands out. Ricardo Correia de Matos, president of the ULS of Aveiro, was detained in the Batas & Betão operation and dismissed by the minister shortly afterwards. He is accused of corruption, economic participation in business, abuse of power and influence peddling. Investigators allege he devised an illegal scheme for awarding works during his time at the Red Cross in Águeda and the Order of Nurses in Coimbra. The ministry also dismissed the president of the ULS of the Algarve after deaths in the emergency department at Portimão, citing the institution's capacity to give patients an adequate and timely response.

What comes next

Gaspar stays in post while the instruction phase runs, and the articles give no date for a judge's decision. If a definitive indictment is brought, he has said he will ask to leave in coordination with the minister. The ministry has maintained that the Tâmega e Sousa situation differs from Aveiro. Its position on the presumption of innocence has not changed.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar