Elections · Madrid

Spanish bishops drop voter note and refer Catholics to Pope's Congress speech

The Spanish Episcopal Conference dropped plans for its own guidance on the 29 November general election and instead referred Catholics to Pope Leo XIV's address to parliament in June.

AI text based on reports by EL PAÍS, eldiario.es, ABC TU DIARIO EN ESPAÑOL and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Madrid · Spain
How it came to this
  1. 2011Last CEE note guiding Catholic votes, under Cardinal Antonio María Rouco Varela
  2. 8 JunPope Leo XIV addresses the Cortes Generales in Congress
  3. 16 NovLuis Argüello says the bishops may publish a voting note
  4. 20 NovPlenary issues a short note referring voters to the papal speech

A note that failed to pass

The Spanish Episcopal Conference (CEE) held its plenary assembly in Madrid this week, a session heavily shaped by the campaign for the general election on 29 November. On Monday, 16 November, the conference's president, Luis Argüello, said the bishops might publish an official note to guide Catholics in their vote. That plan collapsed. According to the secretary general, César García Magán, the draft won more than an absolute majority in the assembly but not the two-thirds that the conference statutes require for documents of this kind. Media accounts of the failure contradicted each other: some said the draft was loaded with far-right ideology, while others said it was too soft. The conference's last note guiding votes dates from 2011, when Cardinal Antonio María Rouco Varela presided over the bishops.

A short note and the Pope's speech

Instead, the assembly approved a brief final note that refers Catholics to the speech Pope Leo XIV gave in Congress on 8 June, the first address to the Spanish parliament by a pope in the country's history. The note asks readers to read or re-read that text in order to form a moral judgement in line with the Church's social doctrine before casting their ballot. García Magán read the central passage aloud and said:

“The assembly has not considered it necessary to draw up its own declaration, but to refer to the extraordinary speech delivered by Pope Leo XIV.”

César García Magán

The papal speech covered a respectful welcome for immigrants, opposed abortion and euthanasia, criticised political polarisation and raised concerns about artificial intelligence. El País noted that some of its positions sat closer to the government and others to the opposition. The final text also drew a unanimous and prolonged ovation in Congress, according to La Vanguardia.

Divisions over Argüello's leadership

Argüello, archbishop of Valladolid, has taken openly political positions, a clear contrast with his predecessors, cardinals Juan José Omella and Ricardo Blázquez, who kept a more cautious profile. Other bishops pushed back against him, among them Joan Planellas, archbishop of Tarragona and president of the Tarraconense Episcopal Conference, which groups the ten Catalan dioceses. Planellas has said that the Church cannot be identified with any political option. García Magán acknowledged that the draft was presented by the president and had first been worked on by the Executive Committee before going to the plenary. He rejected the idea that the bishops had moved against Argüello, insisting the episcopate had not staged a vote of no confidence. Several prelates, however, told elDiario.es that Argüello left the plenary weakened, and he cannot stand in the elections for the presidency of the Casa de la Iglesia, due next year.

The Church's stance on the vote

García Magán also used the assembly's closing remarks to reject political use of the Church. He asked that the Church not be used in political debates in the way he described:

“Nobody should use the Church as a bargaining chip or as a weapon in political debates.”

César García Magán

He also reaffirmed that the Church does not have a political party. Reports of the failed note surfaced midweek, before the final short text was released. The general election takes place on 29 November.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Madrid, Spain

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar