Business · London

UK tribunal dismisses £2 billion PlayStation Store overcharging claim against Sony

A Competition Appeal Tribunal in London ruled on 17 November that the claimants had not shown Sony's margin on PlayStation software and add-on content was excessive. The claim, brought for about 12.2 million UK owners, had sought around £2 billion in damages.

AI text based on reports by Adnkronos, engadget, La Razón and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

London · United Kingdom
How it came to this
  1. 2022Alex Neill brings the claim on behalf of UK PlayStation owners
  2. March 2026Trial begins at the Competition Appeal Tribunal
  3. 17 NovTribunal dismisses the claim against Sony
  4. January 2028Sony plans to begin withdrawing physical game sales

The claim and the ruling

On 17 November the Competition Appeal Tribunal in London dismissed a claim against Sony over the prices of PlayStation software and add-on digital content sold through its online store. Consumer advocate Alex Neill brought the case in 2022 on behalf of an estimated 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners, seeking around £2 billion in damages. The claimants argued that Sony abused a dominant position by setting unfairly high prices, in part through the 30 percent cut it takes on digital sales. The tribunal concluded that the claimants had not established that the margin charged by Sony was excessive. It also found the market definitions used an unsafe basis for judging Sony's conduct, and it was not satisfied that Sony held a dominant position or that its practices were exclusionary or exploitative.

Why the tribunal rejected the case

The tribunal said players had alternatives to PlayStation Store games, namely physical copies and rival consoles. It rejected the argument that players were trapped in a closed ecosystem and dismissed the claim that games would have been 20 percent cheaper without Sony's practices. The ruling also found that buyers had access to sufficient information to make informed choices when purchasing consoles, including the prices of games. The tribunal cited Sony's own research, which warned the company would lose business if its prices were not competitive with Xbox.

The claimants' case

Robert Palmer KC, appearing for the claimants, said that publishing content for PlayStation was subject to a contractual condition that it not be distributed digitally by any other means without Sony's consent. He said Sony designed the console and its operating system to prevent downloads from any other source, and that restrictive licence conditions stopped users from trying to bypass those controls. The KC told the tribunal:

“The result is that Sony can and does set the retail prices of all such content itself without facing any retail competition for digital content.”

Robert Palmer KC

The claimants' position was that the absence of any rival storefront left Sony free to set those prices.

Sony's defence

Sony told the court its distribution model was justified, partly because allowing third-party stores for downloads would introduce security and privacy risks. Supporting third-party storefronts would be prohibitively expensive and would diminish security and performance, the company argued. Sony also said it invests heavily in hardware and sells consoles at a relatively low margin to build a user base. In its account, the commission on digital sales forms part of a cross-subsidisation strategy that covers those costs. Sony maintained that its profit margin on software and content reflected fair competition rather than excess.

Physical games and rival platforms

Sony plans to begin withdrawing sales of physical games from January 2028, according to plans the company has communicated. The tribunal weighed physical copies as one of the alternatives available to players, a route Sony intends to narrow over time. The same competition tribunal ruled against Apple in 2025, finding that the App Store's 30 percent cut on digital sales was an abuse of dominance. Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo each run their own digital storefronts, and a ruling against any of them could open the door to third-party stores. The UK decision keeps the current system in place, while PlayStation faces similar claims in other regions whose outcomes could matter for how digital stores operate.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar