Diplomacy · Shenzhen

Trump, Xi and Putin meet in Shenzhen on nuclear arms control, Yalta comparisons follow

Xi Jinping hosts Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen for talks on nuclear arms control, with the wars in Ukraine and Iran also in view. The meeting has drawn comparisons with the 1945 Yalta conference, which one academic calls exaggerated.

AI text based on reports by LaSexta, EL PAÍS and europa press. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Shenzhen · China

Agenda centred on nuclear arms control

Chinese President Xi Jinping hosts US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, in southern China, in a meeting Europa Press describes as without precedent among the leaders of the three largest nuclear powers. The agenda centres on nuclear arms control, a subject Washington has pressed for years and one that brings China to the table. Doubts persist about the real capacity of China's arsenal, particularly after the United States and Russia allowed the New START treaty to lapse. Beijing says the three leaders will hold an in-depth exchange of views on important questions affecting world peace. Putin pointed to great potential benefits from leaders sitting at one table to settle disagreements on politics, economy and security. The talks also keep the wars in Ukraine and Iran in view, with the aim of ending both.

Yalta comparisons

Europa Press notes that the meeting has drawn comparisons with the Yalta conference of 1945, which shaped the international order at the end of the Second World War. José María Peredo, professor of communication and international politics at the Universidad Europea, calls those comparisons exaggerated. He nonetheless considers it important that the three largest nuclear powers sit around one table. El País argues that Putin would like the Shenzhen meeting to repeat Yalta, which divided Europe into spheres of influence. The Kremlin had floated renegotiating the security architecture of the continent, and the White House had welcomed the idea. Volodímir Zelenski has warned against that outcome in these words:

“We do not want this to become a Yalta 2, 3, or 4 with a redistribution of influence.”

Volodímir Zelenski, ukrainian president

The same editorial argues the parallel does not hold, because the three Shenzhen leaders have not won a war together and do not share the aims that Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill had in 1945.

Weakened leaders and the US position

El País describes Russia as nearly five years into its war in Ukraine, having advanced only a few kilometres in that time, and says its economy is under drastic sanctions from the European Union. The editorial puts Russian combatant deaths at the front at 450,000 and portrays Putin as a weakened leader seeking the spotlight of international diplomacy. It also says Trump arrives after a clear defeat in the legislative elections, partly due to the economic impact of what it calls his failed military adventure in Iran and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz. The editorial frames the gathering as a sum of weaknesses in which Xi stands to benefit, since his role as host lets him project influence.

Fesser's reading of the photo

Speaking from the El Intermedio studio on LaSexta, Guillermo Fesser says Xi and Putin are playing with Trump 'like a small child', drawing him into a club of autocrats for a photo. He says Trump has lost the majority in the Senate and that Congress has warned the Trump family not to destroy documents. Fesser also says Ukraine bombed the bridge linking Crimea with Russia, and that the photo with the two other leaders does Putin a favour. He contrasts the United States of García Lorca's New York visit a century ago with a country he now sees as nostalgia. Fesser closes with this remark:

“It is very frightening that these three guys are taking a photo together right now.”

Guillermo Fesser, commentator

Trump heads to Asia

Before leaving for Asia, Trump said:

“I think we are very close to achieving it. We are going to have a good meeting on that subject.”

Donald Trump, US president attending the Shenzhen summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin

Europa Press reports that his tour first takes him to the Philippines, for the summit of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). Trump plans to use the Shenzhen meeting to press Russia toward steps that end the war in Ukraine. The talks put arms control, not a territorial settlement, at the centre of the agenda.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar