StoryAPEC summit in Shenzhen

Diplomacy · Shenzhen and Naples

Putin says Kyiv and Europe not ready for compromise after Shenzhen summit

Putin, speaking at a press conference after the Shenzhen trilateral with Trump and Xi, said Ukraine and Europe are not yet ready to compromise and called Russia's European security demands legitimate.

AI text based on reports by ANSA.it, Il Fatto Quotidiano, Il Messaggero and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Kremlin.ru, CC BY 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons, cropped)

Seating and opening moves

Presidents Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met in Shenzhen, China, for a trilateral meeting. Tgcom24 reported that Trump shook hands with Putin in view of Xi at the start of the summit, then reached out to help Xi up an escalator. Xi hugged Trump on his arrival, a display that Tgcom24 compared with Mao welcoming Khrushchev in 1959, during the Sino-Soviet crisis. The same outlet said Putin arrived carrying an 'atomic briefcase' and that Trump tried to persuade him to stand between Trump and Xi for the group photo. The Russian agency Tass reconstructed the seating, placing Putin to Xi's right and Trump to Xi's left, and called the meeting the 'first meeting in history' of the leaders of China, Russia and the United States.

Putin on Ukraine and European security

Speaking at a press conference after the trilateral, Putin said Ukraine and Europe are not yet ready to compromise to end the conflict, according to reports carried by Tass. He described Russia's demands on European security as legitimate. Citing Ria Novosti, he said Moscow had accepted the compromises proposed by the United States. Putin called the trilateral 'a page in the history of diplomacy' and said he hoped for more meetings with the leaders of China and the United States. He added that nobody could yet say what would happen next, but that he wanted mutual understanding between the parties.

Italy and the Yalta comparison

Italy's foreign minister Antonio Tajani, speaking on the sidelines of the MED Dialogues conference in Naples, rejected comparisons with the 1945 gathering where Winston Churchill, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Joseph Stalin shaped the postwar future of Germany and Europe. He framed the Shenzhen meeting in these words:

“This is not a new Yalta but a meeting between the leaders of three major countries.”

Antonio Tajani, italian Deputy Premier and Foreign Minister

Tajani said he hoped the meeting would contribute to peace by resolving both the Hormuz issue and the Ukraine issue. He also restated Italy's position on the war, and set out the point in these terms:

“Ukraine must not be defeated, and peace cannot be achieved without a European presence.”

Antonio Tajani, italian Deputy Premier and Foreign Minister

Tajani's remarks were made in Naples, while the summit itself took place in Shenzhen.

Trump's ICC remarks and the EU response

At the opening of the trilateral, Trump had described the International Criminal Court as 'out of control'. A joint declaration by the United States, China and Russia urges the court and similar bodies not to abuse their jurisdiction. Asked about both points at its daily press briefing, a European Commission spokesperson said the EU remains firmly committed to a rules-based international order, of which the court is a fundamental part. The spokesperson said the declaration had been published only minutes earlier and that Brussels would keep following the trilateral, but that it was too early to comment on its content in detail. The spokesperson also pointed to the EU's consolidated position in support of the court, set out in a statement issued some months earlier.

Reactions in the Italian press

An opinion column in Il Fatto Quotidiano criticised what it described as the hostile tone of mainstream Italian newspapers toward the summit. It argued that this criticism reflects a refusal to accept that the world is no longer unipolar, and that Europe should negotiate with Russia for a stable peace in Ukraine. The column proposed that Europe build a security framework acceptable to all parties instead of staying tied to the United States. It backed the general strike and the student and popular mobilisation scheduled for 20 November, which it said could send a signal against war.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Shenzhen, Naples · China, Italy

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar