Diplomacy · Shenzhen, Berlin, and Moscow

Trump, Xi and Putin meet in Shenzhen, and European commentators say Europe lost out

Trump, Xi and Putin met in Shenzhen, the first meeting of the three heads of state, and German commentators judged the pomp greater than the results. A Berlin coalition of 40 countries, initiated by Friedrich Merz, drew the contrast.

AI text based on reports by stern.de, N-tv, Süddeutsche Zeitung and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Kremlin.ru, CC BY 4.0 (cropped)

Pomp over substance

Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese leader Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump met in Shenzhen, the first time the heads of state of Russia, China and the United States have met together. German press reactions agreed that the staging outweighed the results. Putin said Trump persuaded him to invite Europeans to negotiations on the war in Ukraine in Moscow. A joint declaration was issued, and one commentary said that if the three capitals really discuss how to lower the risk of nuclear war, the meeting was worth it.

Commentators split on the winner

Commentators named different winners. The Austrian paper Der Standard wrote that Trump and Putin are both stuck in wars with middle powers they cannot win, while China faces economic and demographic problems that Xi's autocratic regime neither seeks nor finds solutions for. The Neue Zürcher Zeitung judged the summit a success for Putin, who was received with full honours while Russian attack drones flew over Odesa and Zaporizhzhia. For Xi, the paper described it as the diplomatic high point of his term, since he is the only one at the table without a costly war to end. It added that China supports the Russian and Iranian arms industries through trade while presenting itself as a peacemaker. N-tv's press review carried the headline that Europe comes out of Shenzhen humiliated, arguing that the three powers regard Europe as unimportant and that Russia answered Trump's late demand to include the EU in future talks with a cool reaction.

A counter-summit in Berlin

The Rhein-Neckar-Zeitung contrasted Shenzhen with a meeting in Berlin initiated by Chancellor Friedrich Merz, which 40 countries joined to confront Russia over the war in Ukraine. The paper argued that Ukraine's backers are growing tired of paying, and that Germany no longer wants to carry the EU's share alone. After the Berlin gathering, Merz sent a message to Moscow and demanded equal footing for Ukraine.

“It is time to lay down the weapons.”

Friedrich Merz, german chancellor

Nicole Deitelhoff, director of the Leibniz Institute for Peace and Conflict Research, said the Berlin counter-summit had succeeded and showed unity and the capacity to act.

Talk-show verdicts and Europe's seat

On ZDF, Maybrit Illner's talk show, titled "Trump, Putin, XI - neue Weltordnung ohne Europa?", brought together five experts, including the SPD politician and former foreign minister Sigmar Gabriel. Gabriel said China staged the meeting to show how important it is, and he named Putin the winner because Putin is back. He also said Putin never expected that the EU would hold out for five years. Gabriel's verdict on the three leaders was blunt.

“There were three hypocrites talking about peace.”

Sigmar Gabriel, SPD politician and former foreign minister

Sergey Lagodinsky, foreign policy spokesman of the Greens in the European Parliament, said the aim was clearly to redivide Europe.

“The goal is clearly the redivision of Europe.”

Sergey Lagodinsky, greens foreign policy spokesman in the European Parliament

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Shenzhen, Berlin, Moscow · China, Germany, Russia

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar