Diplomacy · Shenzhen

Trump, Xi and Putin meet in Shenzhen, and the Yalta comparison falls flat

The first trilateral meeting of Trump, Xi and Putin lasted 80 minutes in Shenzhen and produced a short statement that does not mention the war in Ukraine. On arrival Putin was received by a Central Committee secretary rather than by Xi Jinping.

AI text based on reports by stern.de, Wirtschafts Woche, Blick.ch and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Kremlin.ru, CC BY 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons, cropped)
How it came to this
  1. Trump arrivalXi greets Trump personally at the airport, hours before Putin's arrival
  2. Putin arrival, 18 NovemberCai Qi, a Central Committee secretary, meets Putin instead of Xi
  3. Group photoXi asks Putin to stand further away, next to Xi's wife
  4. Joint statementThe three leaders issue a short statement that does not mention the war in Ukraine

Yalta comparison before the summit

Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met together for the first time in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the APEC summit. Before the meeting, commentators drew comparisons with the 1945 Yalta conference, where Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill divided Europe into spheres of influence. Wolodymyr Selenskyj warned of a 'second Yalta', and Europeans feared the three leaders could carve up the world between them. Putin had said before leaving for China that he expected considerable potential benefit from the talks. Presumably Moscow wanted to present Russia as an indispensable actor in global security, even though the country has been diplomatically isolated since its war in Ukraine began.

Putin's reception in Shenzhen

Putin's arrival on Wednesday, 18 November, showed how far he was pushed into the background. Xi did not meet him at the airport, as he had personally greeted Trump hours earlier; instead Cai Qi, a secretary in the Central Committee secretariat of the Chinese Communist Party, received him. Cai is 1.85 metres tall, while Putin is 1.70 metres. At the group photograph, Xi asked Putin to stand further away, next to Xi's wife, and video footage shows the corners of Putin's mouth turned down as he appeared visibly irritated.

A joint statement without Ukraine

The three leaders issued a short joint statement that Wirtschafts Woche describes as largely non-binding. Trump gained an announced dialogue on nuclear risks, Xi a commitment to reforming the United Nations, and Putin criticism of international courts. That last point is awkward for Putin, against whom the International Criminal Court has an arrest warrant in place. The three also agreed to increase production and supply of petroleum products. The war in Ukraine is not mentioned in the statement at all. Blick counts the meeting at only 80 minutes and reports that no big breakthrough came out of it.

Three leaders with weakened positions

The meeting exposed how little room the three leaders have to act freely at home. Trump suffered a painful defeat in the midterm elections, and the Democrats now control both chambers of Congress, which limits his domestic power. Putin has been fighting the war in Ukraine for almost five years, and an estimate from the Atlantic Council cited by Blick puts Russian dead and wounded at about 1.5 million. Italian senator Carlo Calenda told the Wall Street Journal that the meeting was a summit of three weaknesses. Xi faces a property crisis, a shrinking population and weak demand, and China's export machine needs buyers abroad.

Crimean bridge under attack

During the summit week Ukraine attacked the Crimean bridge several times, and the structure linking the annexed peninsula to Russia was badly damaged. Wirtschafts Woche presents the strikes as a sign of how vulnerable Russia remains. Putin, meanwhile, called for the international legal system, including the UN Charter, to be strengthened and spoke of a balanced settlement of interests. He also said the three countries share numerous interests in settling regional conflicts, including the conflict in Ukraine. Trump's room for manoeuvre is also constrained, as the Democrats' control of Congress can slow his agenda.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Shenzhen · China

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar