Safety · Shenzhen, Riyadh, and Berlin

Trump, Xi and Putin meet in Shenzhen, avoiding a Yalta-style carve-up

The first trilateral meeting of the US, Chinese and Russian leaders, held at a Shenzhen resort on 19 November, produced a declaration rather than a division of the world. Commentators are split on whether its promises on fuel and state immunity amount to a rebuff to the International Criminal Court.

AI text based on reports by Rzeczpospolita, inews.co.uk, The Economist and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Kremlin.ru, CC BY 4.0 (cropped)
How it came to this
  1. 2 FebUS-Israeli attack on Iran begins the wider conflict
  2. 3 NovDemocrats win the US midterm elections
  3. 18 NovTrump arrives in Shenzhen for the APEC summit
  4. 19 NovTrilateral summit of Trump, Xi and Putin at the Kylin Resort

No carve-up, but no calm

Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met on 19 November in a secluded villa inside the Kylin Resort, a lakeside compound outside Shenzhen, in what New Statesman describes as the first meeting of the leaders of the United States, China and Russia. Trump had arrived on 18 November for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, where a military guard, performers and fighter jets greeted him while Xi waited for him on a red carpet. Commentators had compared the trilateral to the Yalta conference of 1945, when Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin shaped the postwar order, but the three leaders issued the China-Russia-US Declaration toward Peace instead. The Economist judged the staging dire in symbolism, noting that Xi choreographed proceedings to place Trump above Putin while keeping both below himself.

Promises on fuel, immunity and nuclear risk

The Economist reports that the three leaders promised more refined fuels, a benefit for Russian exports, and a pledge to respect the immunity of state officials. It reads that immunity pledge as, in effect, a rejection of the International Criminal Court's war-crimes arrest warrant for Putin. The magazine expects the promised dialogue on reducing nuclear risks to do little to revive arms control. Even so, the summit helped Putin shed his pariah status, according to the same analysis.

Europe sidelined from Ukraine talks

Ukraine was on the trilateral agenda, and the three discussed the war at the American president's initiative. Al Jazeera reports that the US envoys tasked with ending it, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, travelled to Berlin to brief Ukrainian and European leaders, who were determined not to be shut out of decisions. The Economist adds that European leaders met separately in Berlin, and that Trump called them to tell them to stop supporting Ukraine. Volodymyr Zelenskyy, waiting for his debrief in Berlin, argued that questions concerning Ukraine must be settled with Ukraine and those concerning Europe with Europe. Any deal struck in Shenzhen would therefore still have to win acceptance from the parties directly involved in the conflict.

Wars that set the agenda

Patrick Cockburn credits the wars with the Democrats' victory in the 3 November US midterm elections. Al Jazeera says that vote handed both chambers of Congress to the Democrats, and that Trump arrived in Shenzhen after it. The US-Israeli attack on Iran on 2 February came on top of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which began four years earlier, and Al Jazeera reports that the Iran war has rattled oil and energy supplies and disrupted shipping through the Strait of Hormuz. Putin came to the summit with the war in Ukraine in its fifth year, and Cockburn writes that on 19 November the Houthis struck the tallest skyscraper in Riyadh, which houses a sovereign wealth fund with $900bn in assets.

Beijing's restraint

Al Jazeera argues that China is gaining influence through restraint, since two of the three leaders are stuck in wars they cannot end while Beijing is fighting neither. Invoking the wartime alliance, Xi urged the three countries to abandon "Cold War thinking" and said:

“When major countries live in harmony, the world enjoys peace; when major countries clash, the world falls into turmoil.”

Xi Jinping, president of China

Chinese officials have offered a counterfactual: had China armed Russia, the battlefield would look different today. Strategists describe Beijing's stance as "constructive neutrality", and in this account China could have altered the others' odds but held back.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Shenzhen, Riyadh, Berlin · China, Saudi Arabia, Germany

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar